Life is inherently unfair. It's true in business, it's true in love and it's damn sure true in sports. But that doesn't stop us from trying to apply technology and a little design to help even the odds; the original Blackberry and Match.com were ways to stack the odds in users' favor, and much of American-style football is occupied with the review of instant replay.
But the World Cup, as mandated by FIFA, allows no such thing.
This year's World Cup is seeing its fair share of refereeing controversy; U.S. sports coverage was awash with cries of Malian ref Koman Coulibaly "robbing" our boys of a gamechanging goal, and German press can't be happy about the overly officious Yellow Card Mania that was the Germany vs. Serbia game. It's even more frustrating when fans can clearly see the error of calls on the replay; the bar I watched Brazil vs. Ivory Coast at yesterday erupted into derisive jeers after Kaka's send-off, when the slow-mo clearly showed Kader Keita pretending he had been hit in the face when no such thing had happened. (Watch the replay below, starting at about 0:15. It's pretty egregious.)
But the refs can't see the replays, and ever since their 1997 ruling, FIFA has been clear: Video replays will not be allowed to determine referee calls.
Why? One answer provided is that soccer/football is inherently a game of flow, and they don't want to interrupt matches to have the ref running off-field to review a TV after every foul; indeed, one of the reasons I enjoy watching World Cup matches is that a 45-minute half is pretty much 45 actual minutes, as opposed to the four-hour slog of an American Superbowl. But it's not inconceivable that the ref could carry some type of tablet device to instantly review different angles of specific plays, particularly important ones where players are writhing on the ground clutching their faces. Slow-mo replays are available to us fans at home almost instantaneously--couldn't they be beamed to a tablet on-field as well? For the sake of timeliness the ref could have a simple interface letting him choose between several different camera angles, so he could quickly make a determination without having to run off the field.
If done correctly it could all be done quite quickly, during the same time when players are busy stamping their feet and yelling bloody murder at the ref.
In reality I'm sure the tablet would have to be something bigger than an iPod Touch and smaller than an iPad, since the ref is running around. But that's a simple enough detail to work out, and the technology to make all of this work already exists. My guess is that the largest opposition would come from FIFA themselves, or those die-hard fans who claim that unfair calls and human error are just a part of the game. I can accept that, just as I can accept that life isn't fair; but I can't help thinking that a little judicious use of design and technology could help improve the experience for all of us.
Create a Core77 Account
Already have an account? Sign In
By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use
Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.
Comments
The real power of the Ref is that if he believes that a player's action was dangerous in any way then that action can and must be sanctioned, even if a fault was never actually committed. An instant replay may show a hand ball, but if the hand ball is considered by the ref to be unintentional then it is irrelevant. That is where the instant video feedback would mess up the flow of the game and undermine the Ref's role in the field.
Nor does one have to act like Vinny Jones to not be a nancy boy.. Just play the game like a man.
for example:
The majority of decisions are made in the split second before a ref blows his whistle. A team could have scored in the time it took him to view the replay first. And if he blew the whistle and then checked to find out he was wrong - how does he reverse the decision?
A tablet would make things even more difficult for the ref in these situations. It's annoying but mistakes are here to stay.
And in reply to Joe's point:
they're not nancy boys - acting like a hard man gets your team punished (c.f. Vinnie Jones sent off in 5 seconds), so the incentives are in place to exploit this. If flopping to the ground could help you win in other sports I'm sure it would happen just as much. Sad but true!
The beauty about "soccer", Futbol is It's controversy and passion. Sometimes it's in one's favor, sometimes it's not. This is part of the game, this is the game.
I never comment, but this time it was impossible to say nothing.
Cheers