An Introduction to the Crowdfunding Revolution by Don Lehman
By Don Lehman - Feb 03, 2012
If I could convince you of one thing, it would be this: Crowdfunding is not Nyan Cat. Nyan Cat will be the answer to a Trivial Pursuit question in 10 years or so. If it's lucky. Crowdfunding is radically changing the way things are made.
That's why it bugs me when I see the inevitable Internet eye-rolling starting to take place. "Oh great, another Kickstarter project." Look past the avalanche of Apple related accessories. Lower your designer snark rays for just a moment. Just because something is trending on the Twitter, doesn't make it bad.
Crowdfunding is the most important thing to happen to industrial designers and people who are interested in making things since, oh I dunno, CAD? Outsourcing? 3D printing? User-centered research? I know that's pretty big talk for something that's only been in the design community consciousness for a year or two, but think what crowdfunding means for a solitary designer or a small team of people who have a *really great* idea and the know-how to get it made, but no money.
Think of all of the times you have been in meetings with people who make decisions that designers are generally not allowed to make. Think of bringing your hacked up prototype to a bank and explaining to the loan officer that "Yes, even though this is made out of blue foam, the actual thing will be made from molded plastic." Think of building up enough courage to go it alone, and then staring at the ceiling at night worrying if you are committing your family to eating ramen for the next couple of years while you chase your crazy dream. Think of having investors tell you they love everything about your idea, except 80% of it. And the color.
Now think of side-stepping all of that. You refine your idea on your own. You talk to manufacturers and see what it would take to get it made. You work out the budget. You shoot a video marketing the idea and explaining what you need to get it done.
You launch it.
Maybe it doesn't get funded. But at least then you can say that you tried and failed on your own terms, without going tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars into debt. At the very least, you have an interesting portfolio piece to talk about and maybe if you're feeling frisky, you refine it further and try launching it again.
But what if it does work? You get funding. You get confirmation that your idea is good and should exist. Holy crap.
Herein lies the revolutionary aspect of crowdfunding: Product designers can finally tap into the Internet money pipe. For years we have had to sit on the sidelines while nascent web companies attract investors or bootstrap it themselves. It's not because we're lazier than Mark Zuckerberg. It's because the cost of entry into shipping atoms is dramatically higher (both in time and money, but especially money) than it is to ship electrons.
To start Facebook you need the skills, a laptop, a server, and a few months of late nights. (This is a dramatic oversimplification. Sorry Zuck and every software/internet developer ever.) To start a company that gets something manufactured, you need all of that plus a ton of cash. Prototyping, tooling and fulfillment are tremendously resource intensive. Have you ever wondered why VCs tend to back web startups, but for the most part leave hardware startups alone? Money. Crowdfunding lowers the money barrier.
Ok great, so some dude can get the money he needs to make an iPhone case that mounts to his forehead. Hey, what did I tell you about the snark rays? Let's think bigger picture here. What are the long-term implications of designers having a lower barrier for funding their pet projects?Do you know who Tony Fadell is? Tony is the guy (Well, one of the guys. In any event, one of the major players) behind the iPod and the iPhone. He recently just launched a company and a product called Nest. You probably have seen it before. It's a thermostat that learns your home's temperature patterns and starts to proactively control your A/C and heating for you. The design is a beautiful re-imagining of the classic Henry Dreyfuss dial thermostat married with a smartphone. Needless to say, I want one.
Every review of Nest focuses on how Apple-like it is. Meaning: It works so well that we didn't know how bad everything else was prior to seeing it. The product, the packaging, the way you attach it to your existing wiring (It comes with its own specially designed screwdriver! It has a built in level!), the UI, EVERYTHING! is well thought out.
Now, you could argue that Tony is a genius product development guy, with a great sense of taste, and of course whatever he's going to do is going to be amazing. You would be right. But I have to think that his time at Apple had a major impact on how totally thought through the execution of Nest is.
What about the rest of us? Don't you think that every designer, every person who cares about making stuff has been influenced by the Apple way of doing things?
I think there is a generation of Tony's out there. Call it the Apple Design Generation. You can be of any age to be a part of it, all you need is to have synthesized what has made Apple great. It's not just the marketing or the industrial design (although they are good). It's the expectation for things to function, look good, be completely thought through from the nuts and bolts to the landfill. Most important of all, they need to have a soul.
You can clearly see in the web and software community that this philosophy has taken over. Square, Instagram, Instapaper, Dropbox, 37Signals, Snapseed, Twitter, Facebook, MailChimp, and Airbnb just to name a few. You can't be a successful web or software company anymore without making great stuff.
Its still working its way though product development. A lot of crap still gets made and can be successful. In many industries, the incumbents remain powerful because the cost of entry to compete with them is so high. The only thing that has been holding back product development people who care about this stuff from being able to apply the Apple Design philosophy everywhere, is the money to get into the game. Tony Fadell can get the investor money he needs because he's Tony Fadell. The rest of us need a boost. Crowdfunding is going to enable us to do what all product designers are born to do: make great stuff that puts people, not shareholders, first.
Not all of these projects are meant to live beyond rewarding Backers, and that's OK! Not everything needs to turn into a profit generator. Sometimes the journey needs to be contained, learned from and then you move on. However, I think we will be surprised at how many great companies are launched though successful crowdfunded projects.
Now imagine in five years, the number of companies that function like an Apple, like a Nest, like a Jawbone, like a Method, like a (name of your favorite company here) has doubled because of crowdfunding. Imagine the positive impact that could have on all aspects of life. Imagine if contact lens cases, brewing tea, gardening, cast iron skillets, bike locks, and yes, iPhone accessories were all given the Apple Design treatment. That's when you start to realize the potential. That's why you have to be excited.
If I could convince you of one thing it would be this: Crowdfunding is nothing short of a revolution.
---
This is the part where I start to inject a bit of my own story and get to the point of why exactly I am writing this article that unexpectedly turned into a manifesto. (Sorry about that.)
Around this time last year, I was where you may be right now: I had an idea and decided the only way I was ever going to get it made was to use crowdfunding. That decision set me off on the craziest professional year of my life: I launched my Stylus Cap project on Kickstarter, got it funded, got it made, and shipped it to my Backers.
As I was literally knee-deep in boxes of Stylus Caps that were to be shipped to 1,796 Backers who helped me do something I never would have been able to do on my own. All I could think was, "People need to know what it's like to do this." There were a ton of surprises along the way that were unique to running a crowdfunded project that I had no prep for. To say that I would do things differently the second time around, would be an understatement.
The crazy thing is, every project creator is unnecessarily blazing their own trail. That's because there hasn't been much open talk about what its like to run one of these projects. Why or why not, you might want to crowdfund, how to prepare to launch your idea, how to communicate with potentially thousands of people who have pre-ordered your idea, how to run the project on a day-to-day basis, how to deal with shipping.
We need to build on what has been learned. Crowdfunding is still in its infancy and too important to the future of design for us to not be talking about it. So here is my mission: Describe what it's like to run a product design project in 2012, the early, Wild-West days of Crowdfunding.
It's going to be split up into five major parts: I. Should I do this? II. Prepare to Launch, Pt 1 - Build Your Structure IIb. Prepare to Launch, Pt 2 - Tell Your Story III. Communicating with Backers IV. Running your project V. Fulfillment
Should be fun. Stay tuned.
Don Lehman
Don Lehman is a Chicago-based industrial designer and the founder of More/Real, a startup focused on making technology feel invisible. More/Real’s first product, Stylus Caps, turns common pens and markers into touchscreen styluses. Don has been honored by the IDSA, featured in the CES Innovation Showcase, and his design for the Contigo Autoseal Travel Mug was named by Bloomberg Businessweek as one of the 50 Coolest Designs of the 21st Century. He has...
Read more
16 Comments
-
Thanks to Don for this great series of articles, they've been really helpful in demystifying the whole process (of which I'm about to embark). Will parts IV and V ever be posted? Fulfillment is still a big unknown to me, would love to hear your advice and insight!!Report as spam
-
A number of my clients have had projects on Kickstarter. (I'm a registered US patent agent). The key to success AFTER the fund raise is to get your manufacturer on board BEFORE the fund raise. Getting the right manufacturer on board is a serious challenge. You need someone who can deliver low volumes of high quality product in a timely manner.!Report as spam
-
A point you made really resonates. "There are lots of Tonys out there." In fact...Apple has trained thousands of people over the past decade in particular. When I contemplated Steve Jobs most important "gift" to the world I concluded it was his book. It gave all of us (executives on every continent included) unparalleled access to "the process". I, for one, look forward to seeing how that access will influence commerce. A decade from now we may see headlines like "The Apple-Effect continues to spur new economic growth." Put another way...the most lame (but shrewd) executive in America, Europe or China should be able to piece together a team, a vision, a process and a future from the writings of Isacson. Will be fun to watch...and participate in. Oh yea...and crowdsourcings cool too.!Report as spam
-
Very well-written article. Also checked out your product - MORE/REAL Stylus Cap. Dude, that's an awesome idea! Clearly, you've got talent. I'd back up any kickstarter project you consider starting again. Keep up the great work!!Report as spam
-
We are helping a number of our product design customers seek further funding via crowd sourcing its a great way to raise revenue, and judge demand before making the heavy investment in production tooling. Thanks for sharing your experience.!Report as spam
-
Like! I particularly agree with the notion that crowdfunding will have an industry-changing impact on product development. It is amazing what is happening.!Report as spam
-
There is some real interesting lessons to be learned in the communications, i.e updates and comments of the projects found on sites like kickstarter. I have been following how designers are dealing with the fallout of their projects getting 2000% funded and their inability to cope. There are a lot of people who use the site purely to buy things without even considering the fact that the might be buying from designers who are totally unprepared. There can be some real damage to reputations, but I think this is part of the learning curve for this new way of make/sell. I have over 30 designs I want to put out there but first I am learning from others mistakes on how best to handle the process. This series will be greatly appreciated. Thanks!Report as spam
-
A great beginning, Don, way to go. I can't wait to read the series as it unfolds.!Report as spam
-
Great topic and extremely well written. Cant wait for more, such a relevant article.!Report as spam
-
Will be keeping an eye out for the follow up pieces, looking forward to reading more.!Report as spam
-
I hope crowdfunding manages to completely quash all the hype around its evil cousin, crowdsourcing. What sort of twisted pig could combine spec work and a pseudo-open-source contribution mechanism? (That's to say nothing of being able to sell people on the idea that it's a good thing.) And how could industrial designers sell themselves so short trumpeting garbage like Quirky when graphic designers are in such an uproar over things like Crowdspring? I am very, deeply grateful for services like Kickstarter. It's more than just a very nice idea that offers up new business opportunities. Design is on the verge of massive change. Crowdsourcing threatens to suck the industry's lifeblood dry. A platform to reach out and have the public pitch in directly for the products they wish to see offers hope that the future of industrial design is going to be a good one.!Report as spam
-
Crowd funding is awesome, I've contributed to several projects that turned labors of love into a full self sustaining businesses. Not to get political, but this is the future of getting small projects and businesses off the ground, not the fat cat venture capitalists or begging at the door steps of large corporations for money. The reality is this is the scalable, modern form of community loans. I hope this space continues to flourish and matures.!Report as spam
-
Nice post, I find it hard to explain to people in my circle what a big deal crowfunding actually is. next time i will just sent them this post. @Steven Makers: your right about Rockethub.com.!Report as spam
-
Nice post. Lately I've been in love with RocketHub.com - a more stylish and generally newer crowdfunding platform with heart.!Report as spam
-
Bravo.!Report as spam
-
Just because you get funding doesn't mean your idea/product should exist. Spiderman: Turn Off the Dark was able to raise approximately $75 million.!Report as spam
Continued Reading
-
By Core Jr - Jan 20, 2012
Who Arted? Framing a Curatorial Intervention
What with all this Occupy _______ going on, it's easy to forget the many other messages and demonstrations we pass by on our daily routines.If you're familiar with the Brooklyn Navy Yards, you've likely seen a funny blue fish head adhered to a tree embedded in the fence. Take a...
-
By Core Jr - Jan 11, 2012
The New Dawn: Tapping Social Networks for Design Research Recruiting, by Jan Chipchase
A critical part of any ethnographic/design research project is recruiting the right participants for the study—they are the foundation on which the research is built. The default way of recruiting in the commercial research space is to use recruiting agencies to help connect the researcher with relevant participants—generating a list...
-
By Jon Kolko - Nov 08, 2011
Heart of Darkness: A Mild Polemic, by Jon Kolko
This is the first post in a year-long series, Apocalypse 2012, where our favorite futurists, resiliency and disaster experts examine the role of design to help you prepare for...the end?It's a pretty fascinating time to witness the demise of the most powerful and rich nation in the history of the...
-
By Core Jr - Oct 31, 2011
Designing our Competitive Advantage, by Beth Comstock
Image courtesy of the UN Population Fund. Article by Beth Comstock, Senior Vice President & CMO, GE. According to the United Nations, today we celebrate the birth of the world's seven billionth person. This is both awe-inspiring and terrifying. Awe-inspiring when we consider the new ways that technology will connect...
K
{Welcome
Create a Core77 Account
Already have an account? Sign In
By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use
K
Reset Password
Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.