• Store
  • Design Jobs
  • Firms
  • Awards
  • Conference
e

Core77

Sign In / Join Now;
e
  • Topics
    • Product Design
    • Process
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Business
    • News
    • Furniture
    • Tools
    • Transportation
    • Education
    • Footwear
    • Impact
    • Reference
    • Video
  • Features
    • Features
    • Yo! C77 Sketch
    • Photo Galleries
    • Bizarre Inventions
    • Design Calendar
    • Weekly Maker's Roundup
    • DiResta's Cut
    • Industrial Design Tips
    • Hand Tool School
    • Tools & Craft
    • Design Experience that Matters
  • Shopping Guide
  • Projects
    • Projects
    • Firm Projects
    • Reader Projects
  • Forums
    • Forums
    • General Discussion
    • Students & Schools
    • Design Employment
    • Sketching
    • Software & Technology
    • All Forums
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • About
    • Contact
    • Advertise

Discussion Board Digest: Just What Is Industrial Design, Anyway?

By Core Jr - Sep 03, 2014

  • Join Core77 Today
  • Submit your projects for publication
  • }Favorite This
  • Y1
  • m1
  • U1
  • [1
  • X1
  • H1
UPENN UPENN
Photo by Brian Quan

For our September 2014 Back-to-School Special, we're going back to the basics and delving deep into the Core77 forums to answer common student queries. This seven-part series of crowdsourced wisdom includes a comparison of ID degree options, some pointers on teaching (and dealing with teachers), insight into why it's never too late to get into ID, a handy list of resume do's and don'ts, advice on overcoming design OD, and the ultimate list of pro tips. First up, we tackle a question as old as time... or at least the first time you heard of "Industrial Design."

Just what is Industrial Design? After surveying posts on the subject and consulting our own deep internal wisdom, it's simplest to say that ID is the process of designing objects to look good and work well.

It's difficult to come by consensus beyond that, but the work of industrial designers is at the heart of virtually every industry that entails mass production, from humble office supplies to fast cars. A standard ID toolkit includes CAD programs, drawing tools both OG and digital, but also modeling materials like cardboard, clay, and finds from the Dollar Store. So, are industrial designers dreamers or makers? Are they artists, engineers, or inventors? To explore what Industrial Designers are and what they do, we turn to the crowdsourced feedback of fellow designers (and trolls) on our forums.

Note: This isn't the first time we've turned to the collective wisdom of the discussion boards for a definition; see also Michael DiTullo's "Thoughts on the Term 'Industrial Design.'"

Is ID engineering?

Like many of us, user Forester404 wondered where the line between engineering and ID is drawn. Ralphzoontjens proposed that the dividing line is more of a gradient from conceptual to technical:

In my experience, there are purely designer type of people, involved in the front end, thinking out the innovation and setting up the concepts. There are pure engineers who like to tackle technical challenges. Then there is the design engineer who can handle both, but generally is not as good in any of them. In small firms you may find the last type of person more, in larger companies they will have a separate department for the creative process and one to get it to the factories. This division is often a bit too large in my experience, better concepts come when immediately from the start the technical knowledge is also taken into account.

Noahwangerin agreed that the fields blend, stressing that the purview of both industrial design and engineering are huge! "ID and engineering tend to overlap when it comes to product development... But both ID and engineering have their own spectrum that reach to opposite ends. For example ID can encompass systems, experience design, or concept art for movies and video games. Engineering can encompass stress analysis, performance tests and evaluation." But elsewhere, Bulletproof raised an eyebrow about that notion: "The only overlap I would say between [Mechanical Engineering] and ID is in knowing how to use CAD programs, and knowledge of production methods."

The degree to which they overlap notwithstanding, Cyberdemon puts it simply: "Designers are the ones who need to bridge the gap between the art and the engineering." Elegant—but how exactly does that work?

...typically on large and complex projects the designers and engineers work collaboratively. Where do the components need to go, how are the mechanisms going to work, what are the requirements. The designer can lay a groundwork for this, or it can come from the engineers, it depends on the project. Once the groundwork is laid the designers will usually translate that all into CAD that then goes to a mechanical engineer who will start to detail the parts, make them feasible for manufacturing, add in all the screws and structure to make the part work, and that is what will go out for tooling.

Got that? No engineering chops needed because teamwork is good. But that still sounds really technical.Does art play a part?

User Jack_Daniel asked whether someone with a traditional BFA at the advanced age of 27 (more on that later) could possibly get into Industrial Design, observing that "it looks like to do industrial design people are passionate about physics, geometry, furniture; and are Fulbright holders, and dream about chairs."

Based on a cursory review of most portfolios you'd think ID work was 98% sports cars, improbable bikes, uncomfortable chairs and suggestive lampshades—not exactly the bailiwick of Renaissance Masters. However, those solid-looking concepts take a lot of skill to execute, especially when you're starting from scratch. As Nxakt noted, "drawing and illustration are key aspects of making a visualization real, it is a great talent to have." The same goes for sculptural skills such as model-making and the ability to think in 3D. Anything to help get your idea across quickly and elegantly will go a long way.

In this sense, design may have more in common with a more traditional approach to art—i.e. realism, where technical prowess is a means of effective visual communication—than nonrepresentational modes that prevail today. Yet a solid foundation in rendering is valuable, if not essential, for designers. Whether you're just interested in ID or already practicing, designers throughout the forums emphatically support getting your art skills dialed to a point where you can deliver an idea quickly and accurately. As Bepster put it, "I have a hard time seeing someone getting hired who has no way of visualizing their ideas."

So ID uses fine art technique towards a functional end, which doesn't exactly sound creative... or is it?

Industrial Designers: true innovators or drawing drones?

Just about everyone writing on this points out that the project/team/industry/skill of the individual will dictate the specifics, but most do see the ID field as a creative one. How that creativity is defined is a little contentious and definitely subjective. Do you see creativity in problem-solving? At the micro- or meta-level perhaps? In working in subtle unusual flourishes, or reinventing forms? Or is it just about novelty and control over your work?

Nxakt breaks it down to the designer's thought process: "Do you look at the things around you and think of how they are made, work, and could be better? That seems the key spark of being an industrial designer."

Then again, you could just be sketching in circles; Iab draws a distinction between creativity and innovation:

[Oprah once] did a show on dream jobs. She had a young woman on in her first year as a designer at Ford... She showed a ton of sketches of steering wheels and was quite proud that one of them was going to be used. You know she sketched a circle in a thousand different ways that year. So, she did get to come up with a new circle every time, but she was stuck designing circles.
Creative? Sure. Innovative? Not until the end by my definition.

We also like the long-view take that Ralphzoontjens offered:

There is usually a lot of room for creativity, but if you're experienced enough you'll come to see that even a creative process becomes more like a procedure, kind of basically the same thing every time, the same areas of the brain doing their thing. The only mysterious part there is where the initial inception of the idea comes from. But after it becomes procedural, you may find out there's a depth that comes with repetition, so in the end the loss of 'newness' is just something to accept. You can of course create new challenges for yourself anytime you like.

So there you have it. Industrial design where art meets engineering but remains distinct from both disciplines, and creativity constitutes the very process of design. Still confused? Just read Rain's essay and Michael's op-ed—on why "Industrial designers can in fact be designers of industry"—and it'll all make sense.


Back to School 2014: Discussion Board Digests
» Just What Is Industrial Design, Anyway?
» Which Degree for Thee?
» Tips and Tricks for Teaching (and Learning) ID
» Is It Too Late to Become a Designer?
» ID OD: Diagnosis & Treatment of Design Overdose
» Selling Your Soul (In the Good Way) - Quick Resume Tips for Designers
» If I Knew Then What I Know Now - Hard Earned Advice for Students

The latest design news, jobs & events.
Straight to you every other week.

Join over 300,000 designers who stay up-to-date with the Core77 newsletter...

Subscribe

Test it out; it only takes a single click to unsubscribe

  • }Favorite This
  • Y1
  • m1
  • U1
  • [1
  • X1
  • H1
  • design.edu

Comments

Core77's Design Directory

View all Design Firms »

Core77 Adlets

Advertise Here

Recent Posts

  • Spray Paint Finishing Process: How to Get a Fantastic Surface On Your Models and Prototypes

    By Rain Noe - 8 hours ago

  • Chinese Scientists Develop Wood Composite Made with the Help of Crabs and Shrimp

    By Rain Noe - 10 hours ago

  • Is That Airplane Oxygen Mask Photo an Example of Stupidity, or Bad Design?

    By Rain Noe - 11 hours ago

  • Announcing the A' Design Awards & Competition Winners

    By Core Jr - a day ago

Continued Reading
  • design.edu

    By Mason Currey - Sep 02, 2014

    D-School Futures: Carnegie Mellon's Wayne Chung on Training Designers to Solve Wicked Problems

    Backpack design by CMU design students Rachel Ciavarella, Morgan Fritz, and Chris HenleyThis is the first installment of D-School Futures, our interview series on the evolution of industrial design education. Here we have answers from Wayne Chung, chair of the industrial design program at Carnegie Mellon University's School of...

  • design.edu
    3 Comments

    By Mason Currey - Sep 02, 2014

    Introducing 'D-School Futures,' Our Interview Series on the Evolution of Industrial Design Education

    ID students at the Savannah College of Art and DesignSeptember is here, and you know what that means—the start of National Honey Month, yes, but also the reluctant acceptance by most students (and professors) that summer is really over and school is really underway for another semester. Here at Core77,...

  • design.edu

    By Core Jr - Sep 02, 2014

    Presenting the Core77 September 2014 Education Special

    Photos credits: Jaineel Shah, Kyle Oldfield, Valdemar Haugaard OlsenThe equinox may be a few weeks out, but here in the States, Labor Day weekend marks the cusp of the seasons, when we must transition from the long, diverting days of summer to the deskbound marathon of fall. This is especially...

  • Technology
    1 Comment

    By Moa Dickmark - Aug 25, 2014

    Women Engineers Pakistan: Introducing Pakistani Girls to the Field of Engineering

    A few months ago, I was contacted by an organization called Women Engineers Pakistan, which introduces girls to the field of engineering and technology. Just reading the name made me curious. For those of you who don't know, I'm an architect, and I come from a family full of engineers...

K

{

Welcome

  • YSign In with Facebook
  • mSign In with Twitter
  • USign In with Linkedin
OR
  • jSign In with Core77 Account
  1. Forgot password?
  • Cancel

Don't have an account? Join Now

K

{

Welcome

Create a Core77 Account

  • YJoin Now with Facebook
  • mJoin Now with Twitter
  • UJoin Now with Linkedin
OR
  • jJoin Now with Email
  • Cancel

Already have an account? Sign In

By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use

K

Reset Password

Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.

  • Cancel
Today On the Core77 Network...
  • ]Design Jobs

    • Graphic Designer

      Neoscape Boston, Massachusetts
    • Product Designer

      Confidential Costa Mesa, California
    • Graphic Artist

      Augusta Sportswear Augusta, Georgia
    • Creative Director

      Acer Exhibits & Events, LLC Millersville, Maryland
    • Post A Job
    • View All Jobs
  • ]Design Directory

    View other design services:

    • _Hand-Eye Supply

      • Trusco 2-Level Cantilever Tool Box

        $65
      • Kaweco Highlighter Color Leads 5.5x80mm 3 pack

        $7
      • Hand-Eye Supply 6 PC Screwdriver Set

        $50
    • *Coroflot Portfolios

      • TOON - vacuum

        Andrea Putaggio
      • Botran & Co | CGI Advertising visualisation & Promo Animation film.

        Marco Serena
    • © 2018 Core77, Inc. All rights reserved.
    • Terms
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • About
    • Y
    • m
    • '
    • X
    • S
    • © 2018 Core77, Inc. All rights reserved.
    Advertise Here