Core77

Design Criticism: The Comet Smart Nightstand

This did huge numbers on IndieGogo, but I don't think the design makes much sense

By Rain Noe - September 29, 2020

in Furniture Design | Tech

Furniture is generally large, expensive to ship, resource-intensive to produce and difficult to dispose of or recycle. That's why I think of furniture as a lifetime purchase--and I don't think furniture should have non-upgradeable technology embedded within it, as technology goes obsolete quickly.

At least 1,123 people disagree with me. That's the amount of pledgers who've backed the Comet Smart Nightstand, a tech-embedded bedside table, rocketing it to $631,502 in funding (at press time) on a $50,000 goal. Take a look at this thing:

Enter a caption (optional)

The top features an embedded wireless charger, and the table is billed as "The only nightstand you'll ever need," which might be true if the current wireless charging standard will never be changed or upgraded.

The demonstrated usage case, where you're meant to store several dozen single-use plastic water bottles inside to slake your thirst--rather than walking over to your sink and grabbing a glass--illustrates the designers' regard for proper consumption habits.

In the video, one of these circles is called out as a Bluetooth speaker...

...whereas the campaign page refers to speakers, plural. Nowhere does it say how many speakers the object contains, but if all of those circles are speakers and not bearings that enable the top's rotation, I count no less than 32 of them (16 visible per side, see below). And the perforations ringing the perimeter suggest there are in fact speakers all around.

The table is circular, which I find an odd choice for a bedside table. It makes sense if you live in a large loft with the bed in the center of the room. It doesn't make as much sense for those of us with our beds against the wall in average-sized bedrooms.

Also, I think having a top that pivots outwards only makes sense if the object is standing in the middle of a room. In my 10x12 bedroom, the pivoting top would either hit the wall or my bed.

One feature I do like is that there's a sensor that detects your feet and turns a light on in the base, for when you get up in the middle of the night to go to the bathroom. But I'd rather spend $20 on a ConnectLight than the $1,000 (for the 28" x 14" size) to $1,300 (for the 36" x 18" size) that the Comet tables will retail for.

Perhaps the early-bird pricing on the Comets helped propel sales: They're being offered at $500 and $650 on the campaign page.

o

Favorite This
Q
5

Comment

Comments

Yiyang Zhang

2 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

This product comes after the Sobro Smart Side Table and Sobro Coffee Table. I would say Comet has a bold design, but Sobro looks much more practical and is more stylish in my opinion.

!Report as spam
Michael DiTullo

2 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

I love the smell of vapor ware in the morning....

!Report as spam
Patrick Sobrak-Seaton

2 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

Besides all the obvious flaws already pointed out, they have removed the power cable in all of the marketing. Imagine using this as a coffee table and having a cable running under your couch. Yikes...

!Report as spam
. JC

2 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

The display on one edge there means you have to rotate the table or somehow walk around it to operate.
I see 4 charging coils with no indication of where they will be, good luck sliding the device to find the coils.
Speakers blocked by solid surface is a horrible idea.

However i can see this working somewhat in a hotel suite setting as a coffee table but not a night stand as the display controls will face on direction, bottled water is a norm, power termination under the desk more easily accessible.

It should be better advertise as a coffee table,

!Report as spam
Jo Mo

2 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

I wonder if the intent is to just raise the money and run? I do not see how any of this is viable at that price point. And I agree that this is a horrible horrible design with zero foresight. Can we also address the fact that it is a white cylinder, which may be considered "minimal", but will inevitably clash with a majority of peoples interiors. It would be nice to see all of that money go to good and sustainable products/brands.

!Report as spam