Core77
e
Aerospace Engineer Designs the Perfect Ice Cream Scoop
By Rain Noe - Sep 25, 2014
If only all industrial designers paid as much attention to ergonomics as this engineer.
Michigan-based Michael Chou is a dad who loves ice cream, and has scooped a lot of it out for his kids. Here's the thing: He likes the ice cream when it's frozen solid, not partially melted, and found that he couldn't effectively get it out of the container using a conventional ice cream scoop.
An aerospace engineer by training, Chou examined the problem and found the standard ice cream scoop was at fault. "Current ice cream scoops are designed in a way that forces you to use weak wrist joints to scoop ice cream," he writes. "When you are scooping ice cream with standard ice cream scoops, you are doing a prying motion. This prying motion puts tremendous amounts of stress on your weak wrist joints. Your brain then tries to save your wrists by not letting you pry very hard—thus making scooping ice cream very difficult."
Using his "engineer's understanding of ergonomic design and mechanical force," Chou hit the drawing board to create a better scoop. Give it up to the man--it took him three years and some 38 prototypes before he perfected his design, and as most of it was worked on after-hours, he calls it the Midnight Scoop.
[With the Midnight Scoop], you're not using the small weak muscles located inside the wrist. Instead, you hold the curved end with the palm of your hand and "push" into the ice cream. This allows you to keep your wrists straight and protected while you use large muscles like your arms and chest—which are significantly stronger than your wrist.
...The handle is also long enough to help you reach all parts of a giant container of ice cream yet narrow enough to fit inside small pint size containers just as well.
...The front scoop section is thin enough to cut through ice cream like butter, and thick enough to last. The base of the scoop design forces ice cream to curl into that appealing ice-cream-advertisement look, every time.
Chou had no intentions of designing a disposable object, and has spec'd the Midnight Scoop to be forged from 6061 aero-space grade aluminum. With a modest funding goal of $17,500, Chou threw the project onto Kickstarter and easily doubled his goal. Here's the pitch vid:
Sure, an ice cream scoop is a humble object, but it's Chou's lifetime guarantee for the object, and overall attitude towards product longevity that really impressed me. "Some companies design their products to last a certain amount of time, and then force you to rebuy the same products over and over again," he says. "That stops here. That's not how a true engineer thinks. And that's not how an engineer would run their business. The midnight scoop is designed perfectly and will last forever."
Rain Noe
Rain Noe is a writer and industrial designer based in New York City.
12 Comments
-
very nice work, Michael. Form looks great. ...That said: you just need to switch to gelato, which is softer, easier to scoop, tastes better and - I would argue - higher quality ingredients. Ice cream shops have their freezers set at an ideal temperature to scoop. You went all out on problem that can be resolved by turning down your freezer or waiting 5 minutes for the tub to thaw. And...another personal preference here, but par-melted ice cream tastes better. So you need to let it thaw anyway for taste buds to absorb the flavors instead of being cold-burned from rapid scooping with that spoon. I'm a minimalist designer, don't get me wrong, the object is beautiful, but people who buy ice cream are buying budget, not hand crafted gelato, and likely won't drop serious money on a scoop.
!Report as spam -
How about this scope from Lunar?
!Report as spam -
As the often quoted maxim goes, "If the problem you are trying to solve involves creating a magnum opus, you are solving the wrong problem." Or, if you're into computer science, "Worse is Better."
Instead of designing the perfect ice cream scoop, why not spend time finding a better way to extract ice cream. I'm sure a loop of nitinol, a stick, and some batteries would be both cheaper and glide through ice cream more easily than even this überscoop. Add silicone, and you can work out an ergonomic shape without much fuss.
Now, don't get me wrong, the project and the process here are impressive. My question is, does it have to be impressive?!Report as spam -
As an engineer, my perfect ice cream scoop would only last as long as there is ice cream around to scoop. We are already in a lot of trouble for building things that last too long. Where is my edible scoop-cone (patent pending)?!Report as spam
-
Dishwasher soaps are caustic and degrade aluminum by chemical reaction, not abrasiveness. The chemistry is complex and is affected by brand of soap, mineral content in water, and even other metals in the dishwasher at the same time. Annodized aluminum is more resistant to these forces, but not remotely "lifetime" resistant. FMD is spot on -- a lifetime version needs to be stainless. But that would probably quadruple the price.
Also note that the "aero-space grade aluminum" claim is just marketing blather. There is no such thing. And even if there were, it wouldn't necessarily confer any useful properties for an ice cream scoop.!Report as spam -
While I don't know for sure FMD's problem with aluminum, but I do know that uncoated it will get destroyed in time by any dishwasher on the market. It does not hold up to the abrasiveness of the detergent.
The natural version will get trashed. The anodized versions could hold up, but for a lifetime? I have my doubts. He doesn't get into the coating type of the white but he does say it will chip if "abused". So again, I have my doubts.!Report as spam -
Aluminum is a poor choice of material for food-preparation utensils / equipment due to oxidation. Aluminum doesn't visibly oxidize as badly as iron does when it rusts, but at the atomic level, the oxidation is fast, and the material easily abrades. I prefer not to have my food contaminated with aluminum with every use. Aluminum is a soft metal in this regard as well.
Additionally, aluminum does not retain heat very well which is why it's used in radiative applications--but that's beside the point, and isn't one of the selling points of the scoop so it's irrelevant. The creator is trying to sell the fact that he can scoop hard ice cream not ice cream that's melted by the scoop.
If the creator wanted to make a scoop that would last a "lifetime," he should have used stainless steel or titanium (on the extreme end). Anodized aluminum coatings are protective but will not last a lifetime under abrasive use, which is experienced during the act of scooping hard frozen ice cream--and if you aren't scooping this kind of ice cream, you probably don't need one of these fancy scoops to begin with...!Report as spam -
The zyliss and culinare ice cream scoops already address this and have been around for more than 10 years, their scoops are designed with an open end so that the user can press down with more force into the tub rather than having to drag up or across which puts more pressure on the wrist. The chef'n scoop also has added functionality and there are scoops designed to go in the microwave to make this easier. 3 years to get to this point! Wow.!Report as spam
-
Why would FMD say the choice of Aluminum is a bad material? I've seen other ice cream scoops made of it. Aluminum retains heat very well so that if you store it at room temperature for home use or in warm water commercially then it stays warm and cuts through the ice cream like a hot knife thru butter. The handle is a heat sink that uses the user's body heat to keep it from cooling rapidly when used. FMD please explain your comment.!Report as spam
-
Aluminium is a pour choice ? Why? It's light and resistant (especially this grade...).
38$ for a tool you shouldn't have to replace in your lifetime and that can be passed down to your kid? Seems honest to me. Then again maybe you'd scoff at a 300$ chef knife...!Report as spam -
Thats right Cold Stone Creamery....NO MORE WORKERS COMP! I mean I guess I get it. Only an idiot would use a microwaving for a few seconds or heating your scooper up like my parents did instead of embarking on a 3 year project to perfect the ice cream scoop.!Report as spam
-
Cool scoop, the choice to use aluminum as the build material is poor, and the price point is a bit insane, but it looks nice at least.!Report as spam
Continued Reading
-
By Kat Bauman - Sep 22, 2014
Seriously? Test Case: Seatylock
Weird Crap On Kickstarter can be a pretty depressing beat, but sometimes the odd and terrible offerings can give us opportunities to reflect, to learn, and to better ourselves. Today I present the case of Seatylock: yet another bike lock/bike seat hybrid. This thing addresses a few common complaints about...
-
By Ray Hu - Sep 10, 2014
The Standards Manual: A Veritable Grail of Visual Communication Available for 30 Days via Kickstarter
The new Apple Watch may offer navigation via a paired iPhone's GPS system, but (Maps bugs notwithstanding) wayfinding used to be a skill, especially here in New York City. While the grid of streets and avenues bears a semblance of intuitive legibility, the sinuously criss-crossing subway lines has long been...
-
By Rain Noe - Sep 04, 2014
A Vibrating Fork, and an Anti-Vibration Spoon. Which Would You Rather Have Designed?
The phrase "First World problems" was trenchant the first time I heard it. Now five years later, with everyone braying it and hashtagging it as the laziest of punchlines, it irritates me. But I guess it won't go away, and that's partially because of objects like the Hapifork and the...
-
By Kat Bauman - Aug 19, 2014
Wave Hello To Minimal Music Posters: Kickstart Your Favorite Waveform Dance Tracks
Second verse, better than the first. Alex Szabo-Haslam made delicate waves last year with elegant printed visualizations of his favorite electronic songs, and he's back at it with an even wider range of artists. The project was born when Szabo-Haslam, a designer with a background in music promotion, had the...
K
{Welcome
Create a Core77 Account
Already have an account? Sign In
By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use
K
Reset Password
Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.
