8 Comments

• 

  Greg McArthur

  4 years ago

  Z

  1Z

  Reply

  This is all about marketing and nothing to do with a well designed, quality product.  

  
  

  The story sounds good - she's a young woman working in an industry we'd normally associate with older men who got into it to connect with her ailing father - but the product looks like something produced by someone trying their hand at knife-making for the very first time.  The kind of person who, when encountering a problem or flaw, simply calls it a point of character and moves on instead of putting in the time and effort to find a workable solution.  Those of you who have gone to school to design have probably worked with these types (They normally don't make it out into industry).

  
  

  If the work was required to speak for itself we never would have heard about it.

  !Report as spam
• 

  Arthur Lynn

  a year ago

  Z

  Z

  Reply

  People have been making knives from rasps for decades...check out the Facebook group..."making knives from files and rasps." Her knives are so amateur as to be embarrassing. Knifes like [much better] then hers usually sell between $100 to $150.As a professional knife maker I constantly hear jokes about her...A primitive knife like hers takes a couple of hours at the most to make...I guess in a world where people pay extra for jeans with holes her stuff makes sense....In the real world anyone paying $800 for one of her knives is getting ripped off.

  !Report as spam
• 

  Schmidty Boogie

  3 years ago

  Z

  Z

  Reply

  Love the creativity and craftsmanship! Sorry to say that as educated some people think there are, they simply haven't learned the simplest things as "if you have nothing nice to say then don't say anything at all", or "treat others as you want to be treated". Our society has given us a new breed of creatures who just go on the internet to be mean and share their misery with others by commenting on people who are actually doing something with themselves. More power to you and I hope to see more of your work! Aloha!

  !Report as spam
• 

  Alex Flood

  4 years ago

  Z

  Z

  Reply

  The fit and finish looks pretty rough, you can get much higher quality, better functioning hand made knives for less money. It is a great triumph of marketing that she manages to sell these knives for $800, but fair play to her.
  

  !Report as spam
• 

  Mike Cheung

  4 years ago

  Z

  Z

  Reply

  Very nice craft work, but I think it's a bad idea combining the tools. The back and forth grating motion seems like it could be dangerous if someone were to go off center toward the blade while swinging their fingers back and forth in the grinding motion.

  !Report as spam
• 

  Angry Bike Wrench

  4 years ago

  Z

  Z

  Reply

  Beautiful, but seems like most of these would be painful to use if you accept proper knife skill means holding the knife in your dominant hand, the food in your non-dominant, and allowing the knife blade to slide on the knuckles of your non-dominant hand.  Maybe the ground edge extends high enough on some that it's not an issue?

  !Report as spam
• 

  Rob Wilkey

  4 years ago

  Z

  Z

  Reply

  These are awesome, and I love her use of unique woods on the handles, but I feel that its worth mentioning that Peace Knives' Remanant series deserves at least a hat tip for being the groundbreaker on this concept.

  
  

  http://shop.pearceknives.com/category.sc;jsessionid=1E6BF5979409D31A91963310AEC5B579.m1plqscsfapp04?categoryId=2

  
  

  Also worth mentioning that his fit and finish in unparalleled and they're all <10% the price of the Chelsea Miller equivalent.

  
  

  But hey, if people pay what you're asking, more power to ya!

  !Report as spam
  • 

    Toby B

    Rob Wilkey

    4 years ago

    Z

    1Z

    Reply

    Using files and rasps for knifemaking is nothing new, they are good-quality tool steel, and can be tempered to hold a good edge. Leaving the hasp teeth visible is cool-looking (reminiscent of the kurouchi hammer marks on some Japanese cutlery), but seems like it would hard get clean and dry - and these will be very prone to rusting, high-carbon, non-stainless steel needs to be cared for.

    !Report as spam