• Design Jobs
  • Firms
  • Awards
  • Conference
e

Core77

Sign In / Join Now;
e
  • Topics
    • Product Design
    • Process
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Business
    • Materials
    • News
    • Furniture
    • Tools
    • Transportation
    • Education
    • Footwear
    • Impact
    • Reference
    • Video
  • Features
    • Features
    • Yo! C77 Sketch
    • Photo Galleries
    • Bizarre Inventions
    • Design Calendar
    • Weekly Maker's Roundup
    • DiResta's Cut
    • Industrial Design Tips
    • Hand Tool School
    • Tools & Craft
    • Design Experience that Matters
  • Shopping Guide
  • Projects
    • Projects
    • Firm Projects
    • Reader Projects
  • Forums
    • Forums
    • General Discussion
    • Students & Schools
    • Design Employment
    • Sketching
    • Software & Technology
    • All Forums
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • About
    • Contact
    • Advertise

Tools & Craft #11: Using the Right Tool for the Job Starts With Choosing the Right Material for the Tool

When to use metal and when to use wood

By Joel Moskowitz - Aug 10, 2016

  • Join Core77 Today
  • Submit your projects for publication
  • }Favorite This
  • Y1
  • m1
  • U1
  • X1
  • H1

In Japan, bench chisels and other chisels for striking are always "hooped," meaning there's a metal ring encircling the butt-end of the chisel handle. See below:

Enter a caption (optional)
Enter a caption (optional)
Enter a caption (optional)
Enter a caption (optional)

This is a good idea since they traditionally use steel hammers to hit their tools, and absent the hoop, the butt end of the chisel would quickly deform and split. 

In the West, most chisels are usually not hooped. So a good rule of thumb is to always use a mallet that is softer than the chisel handle.

Enter a caption (optional)

The reason is very simple. It is cheaper to replace an English joiner's mallet every few years, than it is to rehandle a chisel. Look at the photo below:

The mallet in the foreground is my old one, which I used heavily for at least five years. The mallet in the background has been in action for a few months and only has a few dents. Mallets seem to stabilize with a few dents, and it's typically years before the big cracks start. 

Some of you may have observed that Western carvers will occasionally use mallets made out of lignum vitae, the densest wood on Earth, to hit un-hooped chisels. So what gives, doesn't that contradict what I just wrote? Well, it's to do with the nature of the striking: 

If you're using bench chisels, and especially mortise chisels, you're looking to whack with power. In order to get that power using a soft mallet, you take a longer stroke with the mallet. What you give up there is precision and feedback, since the face of the softer wood mallet distorts slightly on impact.

But if you're carving, precision is everything. A shorter stoke with a heavier, smaller mallet gives you more control. Even if you are removing lots of material you want to do it in a series of controlled strokes, so you don't split away the wrong wood. So a denser, harder, mallet gives you more feedback, you can use a shorter, more controlled stroke, and overall you use less power per-stroke. The tool handle is in much less danger from a carver than a joiner.

So, some of you may be wondering: Which is "better," using a metal hammer and a hooped chisel, like the Japanese, or using an un-hooped chisel and a softer mallet, in the Western tradition? I'll tackle this topic in a future entry, so if you've got specific questions about this, please let me know in the comments below.

________________________________________________________

This "Tools & Craft" section is provided courtesy of Joel Moskowitz, founder of Tools for Working Wood, the Brooklyn-based catalog retailer of everything from hand tools to Festool; check out their online shop here. Joel also founded Gramercy Tools, the award-winning boutique manufacturer of hand tools made the old-fashioned way: Built to work and built to last.


The latest design news, jobs & events.
Straight to you every other week.

Join over 300,000 designers who stay up-to-date with the Core77 newsletter...

Subscribe

Test it out; it only takes a single click to unsubscribe

  • }Favorite This
  • Y1
  • m1
  • U1
  • X1
  • H1
  • Tools & Craft
  • Hand Tools

Joel Moskowitz

  • x

I am the founder and president of Tools For Working Wood, Gramercy Tools, and Brooklyn Tool & Craft (BT&C), the latter names being brands of tools we manufacture or we source and repackage.

Comments

Core77's Design Directory

View all Design Firms »

Hot On Coroflot

JAM BOOKCASE Sven Rudolph
DAINESE - Torque D1: Design Story ( Designer: 2015 ) David Sheridan

Recent Posts

  • SmartBowl: Homeware from Hardware

    By Joshua Skirtich - 19 hours ago

  • A Dental Industry Tool for Getting the Last Drop of Product Out of a Squeeze Tube

    By Rain Noe - 20 hours ago

  • Watch Nicole Gibbons' "How to Disrupt an Oversaturated Market" Talk at the 2018 Core77 Conference

    By Core Jr - 21 hours ago

  • These Bolts Change Color When Tightened Properly

    By Rain Noe - 22 hours ago

Continued Reading
  • Tools & Craft

    By Joel Moskowitz - Aug 03, 2016

    Tools & Craft #10: Six Ways to Make Your Mark (Literally)

    Sometimes you should bring an awl to a knife-fight

    If you're framing out a deck and something's off by 1/4", you can still make it work. But if you're creating a small box with dovetailed corners and something's off by 1/32", that can be a disaster. That's why folks who do the latter type of work often using marking

  • Tools & Craft
    3 Comments

    By Joel Moskowitz - Jul 27, 2016

    Tools & Craft #9: I Finally Got the Machine of My Dreams!

    I've only been waiting for it since I was six

    I know that city kids today want iPhones and Pokemons and Bluetooth speakers. But when I was growing up in Manhattan I only wanted one thing, and I wanted it badly. This came about because my father had given me a book called "How to Run a Lathe." My father

  • Tools & Craft

    By Joel Moskowitz - Jul 20, 2016

    Tools & Craft #8: Rapidly Deployable Lifestyles, Built With Your Own Hands

    Here's how to build some quick, simple flatpack furniture this summer

    Those of you that went to ID school learned to make things with your hands. For those of you that didn't, or for those of you that did and miss having access to a full shop, this post is about simple furniture that can be easily built--even if you only

  • Tools & Craft

    By Joel Moskowitz - Jul 13, 2016

    Tools & Craft #7: We've Republished the Finest Book Ever Written on Architectural Woodworking

    The wisdom of first-rate masters is available in print. Do yourself a favor and start reading them!

    Whether you are in school or not, do you realize how easy it is, today, to get information that previously took people decades to amass? There are a lot of good books on woodworking out there, some old, some new. After the success of The Joiner and Cabinet Maker, which

K

{

Welcome

  • YSign In with Facebook
  • mSign In with Twitter
  • USign In with Linkedin
OR
  • jSign In with Core77 Account
  1. Forgot password?
  • Cancel

Don't have an account? Join Now

K

{

Welcome

Create a Core77 Account

  • YJoin Now with Facebook
  • mJoin Now with Twitter
  • UJoin Now with Linkedin
OR
  • jJoin Now with Email
  • Cancel

Already have an account? Sign In

By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use

K

Reset Password

Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.

  • Cancel
Today On the Core77 Network...
  • ]Design Jobs

    • Industrial Designer/Design Strategist

      The Clorox Company Pleasanton, California
    • Industrial Design/Design Strategist

      The Clorox Company Pleasanton, California
    • Project Manager

      Muse and Company, Inc. Oakland, California
    • Invitation & Graphic Designer: Luxury Invitations, Branding, and Print Design

      Alpine Creative Group New York, New York
    • Post A Job
    • View All Jobs
  • ]Design Directory

    View other design services:

    • *Hot On Coroflot

      • Jumpstart Charging Systems

        Ryan Paul
      • Beverage Dispenser

        Jonathan Smith
    •  

      • ET TOY WORK

        Rurik Tyler
      • ECCO Biom Venture TR

        Ventsislav Nikolov
    • © 2019 Core77, Inc. All rights reserved.
    • Terms
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • About
    • )
    • m
    • Y
    • '
    • S
    • © 2019 Core77, Inc. All rights reserved.
    Advertise Here