Core77
e
A Springy "New" Take On A 100 Year Old Bike Problem
Another episode of 'Bike accessory design that bothers Kat on a moral level'
By Kat Bauman - Mar 29, 2017
Bikes aren't new. Bike saddles, accordingly, are also not new. The according pains in the ass caused by use of bikes and saddles, unshockingly, are not new. The "Rinsten Spring"—the Kickstarting seat spring claiming to make your bike ride smoother, more comfortable, and healthier? Totally not new. But it is getting freshly stuck in my craw.
Enter a caption (optional)Here's what people want: bikes that don't hurt their asses. How do you accomplish that? By buying a one-size-fits-all cushy, springy, minimalist, or "ergonomic" product? Of goddamn course not, and anyone who claims otherwise is an asshole and a pain in the ass of any mechanic who has to clean up after their hollow promises.
Rider comfort is a nearly occult blend of personal fitness, bike size and fit, adjustment, parts choice, and where/how you ride. It shifts with sensitivity, season, callousing, and whether your LBS likes you enough to mention that your saddle is trying to give you colon cancer.
Enter a caption (optional)
Enter a caption (optional)It is not likely to be fixed by a single springy steel rail that offers little or no option for pitch adjustment and cuts dramatically into height adjustment. With that in mind, here are just three of the Rinsten's shock design predecessors (also designed by engineers) and some of their notable features.
Vintage Softride triathalon setupThe Soft Ride Suspension System
These sporty yet ungainly carbon fiber logs were smacked onto bikes from 1989 through the early '00s. The premise was that removing the seat pillar would allow vertical shock absorption (like the Rinsten), while lateral stiffness would maintain efficient forward thrust. Degrees of stiffness were offered, but user experience varied dramatically by weight and height. Bike fit specialists and physical therapists I've worked with still disagree on the ideal amount of hip movement while riding, but the shared tone cautions against too much.
The outcomes of vertically flexible posts: weight-related material fatigue, poor adjustment options for riders outside "average" height/weight range, and vertical movement so dramatic it destabilized correct healthy bike fit. In other words: less butt impact, but more upkeep and less ergonomic body position. Hm.
Vintage Softride MTB setupThudbuster Seatposts
Cane Creek ThudbusterA shock-absorbing seat post with readily available contemporary sizing, a polymer damper and a parallelogram shock. One of literally hundreds of types of sprung seatposts, these are decades old and work to soften upward blows without displacing riders too much vertically. The original is still around, and most brands offer quantified ranges of resistance or adjustment for rider weight and terrain type.
Worst case scenario you wear out a pivot and get a new one. Best case scenario you use the hell out of it for years until the polymer gets old and disgusting and you show up at a bike shop before it opens on a Sunday demanding that some poor soul replace your antique Ghost Busters ooze-post while you grumpily text your coffee buddies. Outcomes: you can get suspension posts in any imaginable size, from $15 past $800, without losing saddle adjustment.
Sprung And Cushy Seats
Vintage Brooks EnglandThese are the oldest and easily the most direct solution for the sensitive-butted among us. If you're a fair-weather rider with an upright bike, you're probably only suffering because you've got the wrong seat or you don't ride enough. If you're a more serious rider and you're still in pain, you've probably got the wrong seat, possibly the wrong seat plus a bad fit.
Sprung and padded seats have taken out the bumps from rides since before we invented concrete. They're self contained packages of dampening materials and cushioning springs, and as you might guess, there's a good reason the springy rails are moored solidly at each end. Their only real downsides are retro styling and weight, but they make lightweight ones for the weenies these days. How did we solve that? By updating the materials, not adding parts to the ecosystem in order to "minimize," and certainly not by reverse engineering a century old system to make it less stable. When chosen carefully for your riding type and butt shape, the outcomes with sprung seats are generally pretty great. The MORGAW seat system is a thoughtful racy take on integrated seat suspension, classics like Brooks and Selle Anatomica now make slimmer and less chromed options, and cushy gel seats are ubiquitous at any commuter friendly bike shop.
Contemporary Selle AnatomicaThe Rinston's designer, an engineer, seems to have suffered the common plight of uncomfortable butt feelings after being off the bike for a decade. Rather than do what we all must do (tough it out through trial and error), he designed a new solution that works in small scale personally replicated testing. Awesome. Hope he's ready to make good on the lifetime guarantee.
Vintage woven seat, used on Pedersen framesThe Rinsten gets 2/10 for being lightweight and affordable. Negative eight for dubious claims, dubious R+D, and solving a problem that already has thousands of clearer and more user-friendly solutions.
Here's my certified mechanic's DIY design hack for aches after riding over potholes: Swerve and take your butt off the seat next time. You're welcome.
Kat Bauman
Irritated machine-lover and international Portland correspondent.
6 Comments
-
Most of my better fitted saddles work great for the first 30 minutes, then get progressively worse. But I have a theory I should test out...if I swapped out a new seat each 30 minutes I bet I could be quite comfortable for as long as I'd like.
If this is true, the design challenge would be to create a saddle with a mechanical support structure that would constantly move a little bit. Like rearranging oneself in a chair, the pressure points would move around ever so slightly as the shape changed during the ride. A set of linear servos could supply the movements.!Report as spam -
Many people changed their mind about comfort after a trip with Rinsten Spring. Even on a bicycle with full amortization, comfort becomes higher. I created this product for myself, but getting a lot of positive feedback from people who tried Rinsten Spring, I realized that this product will be needed by many cyclists. It is not suitable for people who want to win the Tour de France, measure in millimeters the ideal landing in the saddle, consider every gram of weight.
!Report as spam -
Comment on this
!Report as spam -
Minor changes to a bike seat is solving the wrong problem. The problem *is* the bike seat. Try a design that does not put any pressure on the perineum.
!Report as spam-
If your bike seat is placing pressure on your perineum... then you need a new seat. This is a solved problem in seat design many times over. Many reasonable local bike shops will size you for a seat and point you in the right direction.
Seats are designed to place nearly all of their pressure on the sit bones. If the seat isn't... then it doesn't fit you properly.!Report as spam-
I've never had a seat that fits then in 10 years of biking. been to a half dozen shops, tried 8 seats plus different kinds of padding. no joy. I ended up staying off the bike when the damage caused by the seat gave me 3 yrs of chronic pelvic pain.
My urologist pointed out that "you have the wrong seat" is a rationalization blaming the patient. He would love to see the bike seat go away even though it brings him a fair amount of business.https://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/urologic-diseases/perineal-injury-males!Report as spam
-
-
Continued Reading
-
By Steven Johnson - Mar 22, 2017
Steven M. Johnson's Bizarre Invention #58: Unusual Bike Seat for Kids
Make your child the hub of your active lifestyle
Steven M. Johnson's "Patent Depending" series of inventions range from social commentary to plain ol' bizarre, and they always give us a laugh. So we've contracted him to let us publish one every week.
-
By Kat Bauman - Mar 13, 2017
Yea Or Nay? A Textile Bike Lock
The Tex tests my credulity and offers interesting design
The Tex Lock is a cool, textile-heavy variation on flexible bike locks, but it weaves some big promises. After two years of development, their recent crowdfunding cycle is over and super successful, but I'm still waffling. The core of this lock design (ho ho) is a melding of woven construction
-
By Kat Bauman - Feb 24, 2017
A Swoopy Concept Bike Done Right
Keep the spokes, lose the frame, add lights and go
It's not unfair to say most sleek designy bikes are garbage from a practical perspective. Aesthetically speaking designers despise hubs, spokes, angular frames, familiar components and the basic engineering that makes bikes work. Thankfully the Stadtfuchs is a foxy new release from Urwahn Bikes in Magdeburg, Germany, and a pleasant
-
By Glen Taylor - Feb 14, 2017
A Look Inside Firefly Bicycles' Shop
Exquisitely crafted, personalized titanium frames handmade in Boston
Every cycling enthusiast dreams of ordering a custom frame, made to fit their specific dimensions and riding style. Based in South Boston's Dorchester neighborhood, Firefly Bicycles have been fulfilling the dreams of a dedicated client base since 2011. They produce around 120 bikes a year, and will build any style
K
{Welcome
Create a Core77 Account
Already have an account? Sign In
By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use
K
Reset Password
Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.
