Core77
e
Las Vegas Launches Self-Driving Shuttle, Which Experiences Accident in First Hour of Service
A potential glaring flaw in the software
By Rain Noe - Nov 09, 2017
Yesterday the City of Las Vegas launched ARMA, an autonomous shuttle that provides free rides to passengers along a short route. While the shuttle's circuit is barely over a mile, the vehicle is interacting with regular traffic, which it was hoped would provide public confidence in the viability of the vehicle.
Enter a caption (optional)However, the vehicle was involved in a collision within its very first hour of service. By all accounts this was a minor fender-bender, initiated by the human driver of another vehicle, but it does highlight a glaring flaw (or a potential malfunction) in the technology of the vehicle, which is produced by French company Navya.
Apparently a semi-truck was backing up, did not see the shuttle, and "grazed" it, producing no injuries. Here is how a passenger interviewed by Channel 3 News Las Vegas described it:
"The shuttle just stayed still and we were like, 'Oh my gosh, it's gonna hit us, it's gonna hit us!' And then…it hit us! And the shuttle didn't have the ability to move back, either. Like, the shuttle just stayed still."
A City of Las Vegas representative issued the following statement:
"The autonomous shuttle was testing today when it was grazed by a delivery truck downtown. The shuttle did what it was supposed to do, in that it's [sic] sensors registered the truck and the shuttle stopped to avoid the accident. Unfortunately, the delivery truck did not stop and grazed the front fender of the shuttle. Had the truck had the same sensing equipment that the shuttle has the accident would have been avoided."
The key problem, as I see it, is the assertion that "the shuttle stopped to avoid the accident." Yet it didn't avoid the accident. Ideally it would have taken some type of evasive action, although admittedly we do not have the details; was it already boxed in? But failing that, it ought be able to do what a human driver would do if penned in while a vehicle is about to back into it, which is to start frantically leaning on the klaxon.
In any case, the accident was minor enough that the shuttle will continue its trial. "Testing of the shuttle," says the city representative, "will continue during the 12-month pilot in the downtown Innovation District."
Rain Noe
Rain Noe is a writer and industrial designer based in New York City.
5 Comments
-
Maybe is because it's unfortunate acronym ARMA which means "weapon" in most Latin languages. This coincidence could be an ironic reminder of how the technology can become a weapon if badly used or if is immature.
!Report as spam -
The design flaw here is not really the autonomous vehicle, is it? It really did *avoid* the accident. We now have 2 buckets: vehicles that operate near-flawlessly an stop to avoid collisions, and vehicles operated by humans. We are, statistically, TERRIBLE at driving. It's early, there isnt much detail, but I dont think the robot car is really the problem here
!Report as spam -
I have to admit,"taking an evasive action" to avoid the very simple fender bender could have caused something much worse. It could have sideswiped a car in the next lane if it was two lanes going the same direction. It could have hit an oncoming car head-on. Either one of those could have lead to an even bigger accident. It also could have hit a pedestrian or a cyclist. A human might not have been able to assess all that information in a second to make a proper decision to avoid the larger catastrophes but instead take the fender bender.
!Report as spam-
Let's assume that its programming wouldnt have driven it into another vehicle, bike, person...etc. How about just slowly backing up to use whatever space was available? Perhaps any car present behind it would have seen the situation and backed up also to provide more room. What if all of the cars behind it had the same programming and backed up in series? The real solution to the problem is vehicle to vehicle communication, to bad that seems to be a ways off now.
!Report as spam-
Yes if all vehicles spoke to each other and they all could back up in unison, that would solve this problem. But at that point, they would also speak to the truck which backed up into this bus, eliminating that issue from happening as well.
Its the argument of when we go autonomous driving, it all needs to go in order for it to truly be beneficial.!Report as spam
-
-
Continued Reading
-
By Michael DiTullo - Nov 08, 2017
Yo! C77 Sketch: Digital Car Sketch Using a Simple Color Technique
Michael DiTullo shows us how to create surface differentiation with color
In this video, I show you how I quickly sketch a car using a very simple color technique. Using sky tones for all of the upward facing surfaces and warm tones for all of the ground facing surfaces, I quickly and effectively show off the surface changes in these two
-
By Emily Engle - Nov 03, 2017
The Future of Transportation Looks Bright at Tokyo Motor Show 2017
This year's edition of the Tokyo Motor Show was all about the concept vehicle. Placing emphasis on what's to come next in the transportation industry, each exhibiting company flaunted their vision of the future vehicle on dramatic rotating stages under massive spotlights. With crowds fighting to photograph the exciting concepts
-
By Rain Noe - Nov 03, 2017
A Great Animated Visualization of the Honda Civic's Design Evolution
It was fascinating to see the styling similarities between the original Honda Civic and the company's newly-unveiled Urban EV concept car. Now the folks at Donut Media have helpfully illustrated how the Civic's design has evolved in the nearly 50 years between those two models: It's probably just nostalgia
-
By Rain Noe - Oct 31, 2017
Waymo Reveals Why "Hand-Off" Between Autonomous Car and Driver is a Terrible Idea
Given human behavior, the company's all-or-nothing approach is a wise one
Four years ago, Google's self-driving car team recorded some in-car footage that they've unsurprisingly kept under wraps, until yesterday. That footage is of what test users were doing while sitting in Google's (now Waymo's) self-driving car prototypes: "Napping, putting on makeup and fiddling with their phones as the vehicles traveled
K
{Welcome
Create a Core77 Account
Already have an account? Sign In
By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use
K
Reset Password
Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.
