Core77
e
The function of a doorway is to allow people to pass through a wall.
The function of a door is to seal that aperture, providing visual and sonic privacy, protection from the elements and denying access to people who are not supposed to pass through that wall.
Given those truths saloon doors, of the sort seen in every Western movie, make little sense. Yet we know they existed thanks to not just Hollywood, whose depictions can be suspect, but the actual architectural record. The question is, what was their purpose?
Enter a caption (optional)Incredibly dumb and obviously specious theories abound on the internet, and with no Saloon Door Authority to set the record straight, all we can do is use our observation skills as designers to deduce their intended function.
Saloon doors, also known as batwing doors, can be paneled, louvered or planked. But regardless of their construction they consistently have two defining physical characteristics:
1) They do not extend all the way to the floor nor the top of the doorjamb, but instead block the doorway at roughly torso height.
2) They feature bi-directional hinges.
Enter a caption (optional)Let's look at characteristic #1 first, and what that says about the door's function. Since they do not seal the doorway, they provide little protection from the elements and are unsuitable for denying access. (Saloons that had closing times were locked after hours using an additional set of outer, shutter-like doors.)
What they do provide, most obviously, is a modest visual barrier. Nineteenth-century saloons were places for men to consume alcohol, gamble and hire prostitutes, all pursuits that were at odds with religious and temperance movements of the time. We can conclude that barring passersby from getting an unwelcome eyeful of these sins--while still allowing the sound to pass through, to tempt the intemperate--was one goal of saloon doors.
Enter a caption (optional)Why not, then, just have a full door? One explanation might be to save on materials, but that seems untrue; if the sole purpose of the door is to block the view, the outer doors would simply be used and no saloon doors would be installed at all.
I think the explanation lies with characteristic #2.
Enter a caption (optional)Saloon doors feature bi-directional hinges and no door handle--as do the doors to the kitchen of every restaurant I've ever worked in. The purpose of a door with a bi-directional hinge is to allow people whose hands are encumbered to easily pass through them, regardless of whether they're going in or out. If the door is reduced in surface area and split vertically in half, therefore greatly reducing the weight, it makes it even easier to push through.
Coupled with a need to provide a visual barrier to licentiousness, if we think of a saloon needing to be regularly restocked by someone carrying crates of bottles in and out, and patronized by cowboys who might prefer to carry their gear inside rather than leave it sitting outside on a horse without an alarm system, then saloon doors make good sense. I believe these were an early stab at UX.
Rain Noe
Rain Noe is a writer and industrial designer based in New York City.
5 Comments
-
When we think of saloons, it's typically a desert scene. I'm sure they were a good way of letting in a cross breeze, especially if the saloon were nestled too tightly between the barber and the banker to offer windows. They would also allow in
diffused light which would do a few things. 1) you wouldn't have to have candles or a fire lit in an already hot environment 2) You would have eyes adjusted to the dimness but a stranger (or wife!) walking in would be temporarily blinded. You could see the intruder coming from far off but they couldn't see you until they were inside and their eyes adjusted.I bet having the bottom of the door not touch the floor helped with sweeping out the tremendous amount of sand that would pile up inside, and would also make it difficult for somebody to hide just outside the door.1!Report as spam -
These will come back in use because of Drone Delivery.
!Report as spam -
Drunk and Rambunctious Guys were kicking the crap out of the door. Plus, when they needed to give someone the Bums Rush they didn't break any glass. These were cheap and easily fixed and allowed you to see out,if the Mrs. was comin ta getchu. The kids could look under the door and call to you to come home now.
!Report as spam -
Wouldn't be surprised if there was also a workaround to some obscure law. Perhaps it was worded vaguely, saying "saloons shall be hidden from view of the public street" but at the same, they want to let the music and banter flow out to entice customers. Not to mention allow natural light and fresh air in.
!Report as spam -
The function you described makes these seem like the noren (split short curtain) used in Japanese shops.What about announcing someone's arrival in a somewhat inconspicuous manner? A completely open doorway would not make any sound to announce an arrival, but a ringing bell or something like that would be too conspicuous and would likely get annoying.!Report as spam
Continued Reading
-
By Rain Noe - Apr 12, 2018
Unusual Transportation Concept: Flying Trains
"It's crazy--but it's so crazy that it just, might, work"
The always-imaginative Russian concept designer Semenov Dahir Kurmanbievich is at it again. This time he's conceived of a mass transit system that combines aspects of an airplane and a train: Obviously the craft is meant to draw power from the monorail. A monorail system, and the idea of getting the
-
By Emily Engle - Apr 11, 2018
Maude's Line of Sex Essentials Makes Sex a Well-Designed Experience from Drugstore to Bedroom
Trojan who?
Does anyone know a single person that enjoys shopping for sex-related products in drugstores? From hideous packaging to creepy names to the overabundance of available styles—right up to the part where you make uncomfortable eye contact with the cashier—I can't think of a single enjoyable step in the process. Considering
-
By Rain Noe - Apr 11, 2018
Prototyping a New Form Factor for the Desktop PC
Form follows fins
Unless you're a gaming nerd, I'm willing to bet your desktop PC is ugly and hidden away rather than prominently displayed. It is odd that such a crucial object in our work lives receives such little design attention, but I suppose we all need what PCs deliver more than we
-
By Rain Noe - Apr 02, 2018
Finally! Dieter Rams Documentary by Gary Hustwit is On the Way
"If I had to do it over again, I would not want to be a designer."
Dieter Rams appears sparingly in Gary Hustwit's "Objectified" documentary on product design. Perhaps that was for the best, as Hustwit's now working on a dedicated feature-length documentary on Rams, where we'll get to hear about his philosophies, processes and inspiration in-depth. Hustwit has released three teaser trailers: Rams
K
{Welcome
Create a Core77 Account
Already have an account? Sign In
By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use
K
Reset Password
Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.
