Core77

Sign In / Join Now

Topics
- Product Design
- Process
- Technology
- Lifestyle
- Business
- News
- Furniture
- Tools
- Transportation
- Education
- Impact
- Reference
- Video
Sign Up For Our Newsletter
Subscribe
Features
- Features
- Designing Women
- Getting Hired
- Design Files
- True I.D. Stories
- Sex-tacular
- In the Details
- Photo Galleries
- Bizarre Inventions
- Questionnaire
- Materials
- Footwear
- Hand Tool School
- Tools & Craft
Awards
Careers
- Careers
- Design Jobs;
- Talent Search;
- Design Salaries;
Firms
- Firms
- Search Firms;
- Firm Projects
Forums
- Forums
- General Discussion
- Students & Schools
- Design Employment
- Sketching
- Software & Technology
- All Forums
More...
- About Us
- Contact Us
- Advertise
- About
- Terms of Use
My Account
- My Account
- Sign In / Join Now
Follow Us
- )
- m
- Y
- '
- S
Search
e

Prototyping

How VR Is Changing the Game for Product Designers

Goodbye foam core mockups, hello VR environments

By Tom Murray - July 16, 2018

A few years ago when my colleagues were designing an aging-in-place walk-in shower for Jacuzzi, they rented a nearby virtual reality facility to evaluate a simulated version of an early prototype.

The VR facility staffer donned a suit packed with sensors, and the designers on Bresslergroup's project team were able to ask him in real time to interact with different elements of the prototype. Observing how some of the controls were in a hard-to-reach area, the design team immediately saw the value of changing these and other design elements.

Enter a caption (optional)

Today we have the ability to set up and interact with a VR-simulated prototype whenever we need to, and without leaving our office – and the cost is a fraction of what we spent to rent the VR facility just a few years ago. And the technology continues to grow more accessible. If you can figure out how to leverage it for product design, it can easily translate to faster turnaround and cheaper development costs.

Farewell, Foam Core Mockups?

Foam core mockups have been a staple for industrial designers since the beginning of our profession. Once an object gets bigger than two by two feet, it's often useful to build some kind of volumetric model to evaluate placement of controls, positions of openings and doors, and relative scale compared to the users.

I was taught in my first years of design school how to meticulously craft by hand a presentation-worthy foam core or foam model based on CAD drawings. Laser cutters and CNC machines make this process more precise, efficient, and speedier.

At Bresslergroup we frequently build these models for clients to conduct ergonomic assessments and get feedback on in-progress work. Models can be built with moving doors and drawers to simulate usage scenarios and evaluate workflow. In most cases we make refinements based on learnings derived from interacting with these models.

But the larger models, such as the one shown below of the aging-in-place shower, can take skilled designers days and even weeks to construct. And if a large change needs to be made to the model, it again takes time and significant effort to modify.

Enter a caption (optional)

Transporting something of this size has its challenges. If a client isn't within driving distance, in many cases it's not feasible to deliver a model to a client's location. In the case of one model we built of a room-sized lab instrumentation system, we rented a truck to drive it (in pieces) to our client a couple of hours away. Then we re-assembled it on-site.

Hello, Virtual Reality Environments

Enter VR. Devices such as the Oculus rift and HTC Vive have enabled consumers and professionals alike to embrace the technology, experiment with it, and discover its potential.

At Bresslergroup we've integrated VR into our workflow. Our CAD planning still begins in our chosen CAD platform of choice – readying the design for VR requires no extra work. But instead of iterating with physical materials, we can now quickly jump into VR to explore variants more quickly.

Enter a caption (optional)

VR makes quick work of creating and playing around with variants to test our assumptions. Native CAD files can be imported seamlessly into a VR environment in just a few minutes. (Above are screenshots of the shower imported into our VR environment.)

Enter a caption (optional)

Once in VR, different variants and configurations of this model can be evaluated side by side in full scale. Watch the video, above, to see how we can manipulate and move the shower seat and reach for shelves and grab bars while in VR, adding to the immersive experience. When designing products such as these, not only is access important but so is the ability to reach critical areas.

Have VR, Will Travel: Our Portable Setup

The ability to quickly try things out in full scale is an extremely important tool in our design toolbox. But when we want to share the model with our clients, the ability to pack it up and take it on the road is key. Below is a GIF of me unpacking the kit and setting it up – as you can see, it's a lot more efficient than building, deconstructing, transporting, and reassembling a foam core model.

Enter a caption (optional)

Our setup consists of an HTC Vive and a VR capable workstation and of course, a case to carry everything. We have developed a workflow to quickly bring in Solidworks models with textures and shading.

We expect our setup to evolve as quickly as VR evolves (which is to say, quickly). The new Oculus Rift is $199. In a few years you'll be able to get an HTC Vive for that price. Google Chrome now supports web-based VR for the Oculus Rift; and more apps are being introduced to enable us to upload a CAD model, create a scene, and send it to a client. With one click, the client will be able to open the VR scene and interact with our latest prototype.

Enter a caption (optional)

Today VR is usable and affordable for ergonomics testing and to test our own and our clients' assumptions. This lets us iterate and improve a design before we build a prototype. Before VR, if designers and engineers didn't have the time or budget to build foam core models, they would end up with very expensive prototypes that would then require changes. Now we can make sure the first prototype we build is optimized for ergonomics.

In the future, we expect to be able to use VR for user testing. (Check out this report from the recent HFES Symposium by my colleague, Aditi Singh's – she writes about the trend of Using AR/VR Technology for Human Factors Research.) This future is close—and it's exciting.

Tom Murray

Tom became a designer to make thoughtful, long-lasting products — he's not a fan of throwaway stuff. He has a great sense of brand design language, and he welcomes product-branding challenges. At Bresslergroup these range from working with a startup who is branding from scratch to making a legacy brand’s new product line look different even if the guts are the same. He will often be the lead industrial designer on a project, working with the engineering and interaction design leads to illustrate a client’s design options, walk the client through the team’s recommendations, and document solutions. His first step is always to gain a thorough understanding of a client’s manufacturing concerns, branding strategy and impact, and user research. His happiest moments are when a client is uniquely satisfied. Tom earned degrees in Engineering and Industrial Design from Ocean County College and Auburn University. He honed his skills at Black and Decker, where he worked for eight years before coming to Bresslergroup.

7 Comments

Sam Whitworth

a year ago

Z

1Z

Reply

Great article. I'm a student who's interested in a VR workflow. Can you share which software package(s) you use to view/interact with your CAD in VR?

!Report as spam
- Jonathan Hockaday
  
  Sam Whitworth
  
  a year ago
  
  Z
  
  Z
  
  Reply
  
  I've done some VR work at school, I use Unreal Engine 4 to do all of my VR stuff. You're able to import Solidworks models right into it now.
  
  !Report as spam
- Wilson Keel
  
  Sam Whitworth
  
  a year ago
  
  Z
  
  Z
  
  Reply
  
  Autodesk Inventor > 3DS Max > 3DS Max Interactive
  
  Keyshot 8 will supposedly have VR capabilities as well.
  
  !Report as spam
- Roberto Briceño
  
  Sam Whitworth
  
  a year ago
  
  Z
  
  Z
  
  Reply
  
  Right now I'm primarily working with draftsight for 2D and then sketchup+enscape and for very specific stuff (like furniture design) I work with solidworks+keyshot
  
  !Report as spam
- Rhys Kaunda-Mckenzie
  
  Sam Whitworth
  
  a year ago
  
  Z
  
  Z
  
  Reply
  
  If you are a student try out VRED Professional, its what we currently use in the studio (Automotive)
  
  You can get it for free through the Autodesk student portal, then do a google search for "VRED HMD collaboration" file for a basic interfaces and design tools.
  
  You can build custom tools through the script editor, we run a custom interface and toolset.
  
  You may also be interested in Gravity sketch, for HMD content creation (I have seen a number of students complete studio projects in Gravity sketch)
  
  !Report as spam
Robert Grace

a year ago

Z

Z

Reply

Those interested in this topic may also like the story I wrote in the January 2018 Plastics Engineering magazine (see http://bit.ly/Kinetic_story ), quoting Jim Topich and Tony Guard from Kinetic Vision in Cincinnati on how VR and AR are speeding product development. That article is based on the presentation they jointly gave at the SPE Design in Plastics 2017 conference I organized at CCS in Detroit.

!Report as spam
Roberto Briceño

a year ago

Z

Z

Reply

I'm working on archviz and contracto management right now and things like enscape can actually cut the time from idea to production at least by half.
I'm still not into the VR realm,l think I'll wait another year for that.
Things in 3d visualization are getting so nice in the upcoming years...

!Report as spam