• Design Jobs
  • Firms
  • Awards
  • Conference
e

Core77

Sign In / Join Now;
e
  • Topics
    • Product Design
    • Process
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Business
    • Materials
    • News
    • Furniture
    • Tools
    • Transportation
    • Education
    • Footwear
    • Impact
    • Reference
    • Video
  • Features
    • Features
    • Yo! C77 Sketch
    • Photo Galleries
    • Bizarre Inventions
    • Design Calendar
    • Weekly Maker's Roundup
    • DiResta's Cut
    • Industrial Design Tips
    • Hand Tool School
    • Tools & Craft
    • Design Experience that Matters
  • Shopping Guide
  • Projects
    • Projects
    • Firm Projects
    • Reader Projects
  • Forums
    • Forums
    • General Discussion
    • Students & Schools
    • Design Employment
    • Sketching
    • Software & Technology
    • All Forums
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • About
    • Contact
    • Advertise

In Praise of Phase 0: Scoping Design and Development Efforts One Step at a Time

Examining the design process behind virtual reality gym, BlackBox VR

By Ryan Gray - Oct 04, 2018

  • Join Core77 Today
  • Submit your projects for publication
  • }Favorite This
  • Y1
  • m1
  • U1
  • X1
  • H1

Product Development projects include a lot of uncertainty. Specific design decisions and tradeoffs will be made throughout the development effort that will define the look and feel of a product, the feature set, and the production cost. In early development, there is also significant uncertainty around the amount of time, effort, and money required to fully develop the product. While this presents a challenge to leadership teams, it is important to recognize this uncertainty as inherent to new product development projects: unless a product is well defined, it is impossible to accurately project development costs and production costs. And to define the product, some level of development work must first be executed. 

When new clients talk with us for the first time, they often ask two questions: "How much will this cost?" and "How long will it take?". The answer is usually "It depends", but that is typically not acceptable for business decision makers. An initial body of work called "Phase 0" develops the answers to these fundamental questions and frames the broader development project.

When the leaders at BlackBox VR engaged SGW Designworks, they had a clear vision for the user experience they wanted to deliver. Their goal was to re-define the gym experience by creating a virtual-reality based exercise experience. The BlackBox team envisioned developing an entire workout room, with handles in all walls, in the floor, and in the ceiling, all controlled by inputs from the VR system, that users would interact during the workout. The team was anxious to find out how long development would take, and what development would cost. 

Through initial exploratory discussions, it became clear that the vision for the system was based on a lot of assumptions that needed to be examined. For example, while the BlackBox team had envisioned over a dozen interface handles, they were open to using fewer, if the user experience was not diminished. But this decision would drive overall system complexity upward or downward significantly. So, this decision would have a huge impact on development time and cost. Producing an estimate for the entire project without this decision being made first would have resulted in an inaccurate quote. Recognizing that a lot of uncertainty around the system existed, we proposed a Phase 0 project.

Specification Development
The first step in the Phase 0 project was to develop a product specification. In two sessions with Black Box VR, the design team developed the product specification document which is used to bracket all subsequent development effort. The spec document captures all critical constraints, requirements, and inputs. Development budget and target product price can be important inputs to the specification, because both things can drive design and project decisions. Product specifications are living documents and will be updated or revised throughout development.

Working through the product specification exercise identified several critical features and characteristics that represented significant development risks. These features and technologies would need to be examined first, as decisions here would be critical to defining future development efforts and scope.

Feasibility Study and Options Analysis
Our initial efforts focused on clarifying the technology options related to the load generation element. If existing technology could not deliver the needed functionality, the product was likely not feasible. The development team identified eight possible approaches, using existing technology. Each had advantages and disadvantages, which were captured in a decision matrix. The team presented the options and recommendations to the client, and a core technology was selected.

At the heart of the load resistance system is an industrial servo and pulley

Concept Development
Based on the chosen core technology, concept-level work on the most critical system element began. In Phase 0, the concept work is intended to provide a way to think through and debate different configurations with the client. Through quick concept iteration, an initial configuration for a sub-system prototype was defined. 

3D CAD model of the complete load resistance system

Phase 1 Development Plan
With agreement between the client and the development team on the core technology of the product and a conceptual configuration for the first subsystem prototype, Phase 1 work could be scoped and estimated. It is typical for the findings and decisions made in any phase of work to drive the scope end cost of all subsequent phases. Therefore, it is best to define an imminent project phase based on the results of the prior phase, and not on assumptions.

Outcome
Twelve months, and five phases later, BlackBox VR took a fully functional late stage prototype, designed and built by SGW Designworks, to the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas to showcase the technology. BlackBox was awarded a prestigious CES Innovation Award and was awarded Best Startup of CES 2018 by Engadget. Just months after that, steady state production of the system began.

Live demo at CES 2018

Typically, product decisions and research findings that happen in early development have a drastic impact on subsequent development work. In the BlackBox example, decisions made in Phase 0 around the core technology would drive the scope and cost of all subsequent development work. Defining development cost prior to Phase 0 would have been impossible. Even on smaller projects, critical design decisions made in early development have an extreme impact on the overall development effort. The best approach is to scope each phase at the end of the prior phase, with an overall development scope/budget in mind. This ensures that development plans adapt to design decision and findings throughout the process, and stay on track with the overall need and resource level. Deep and frequent communication with client companies through development phases helps ensure that the development work is aligned to business needs, and unwanted surprises are minimized.

The latest design news, jobs & events.
Straight to you every other week.

Join over 300,000 designers who stay up-to-date with the Core77 newsletter...

Subscribe

Test it out; it only takes a single click to unsubscribe

  • }Favorite This
  • Y1
  • m1
  • U1
  • X1
  • H1
  • Case Study
  • Prototyping
  • Tech
  • Consumer Electronics

Ryan Gray

  • x
  • x

Ryan Gray is co-founder and VP at SGW Designworks, a product development and engineering company in Boise, Idaho. Ryan has over twenty years of experience in r&d, product development, and in building high-impact development teams. He is also President of Portsmith Technologies, which produces docking and adapter solutions for enterprise IT applications.

Comments

Core77's Design Directory

View all Design Firms »

Hot On Coroflot

DAINESE - Torque D1: Design Story ( Designer: 2015 ) David Sheridan
JAM BOOKCASE Sven Rudolph

Recent Posts

  • Sphero's BB-8 Rolled into Robot Fame. Their RVR Prototypes Open Up a Much Wider Universe of Possibilities.

    By Kickstarter Design & Tech - 16 hours ago

  • SendCutSend: A Speedy Outsourcing Service for Laser Cutting Metal

    By Rain Noe - 16 hours ago

  • Clever Medical Design: ZipStitch, a DIY Non-Invasive Substitute for Stitches Based on Zip-Ties

    By Rain Noe - 20 hours ago

  • Auto Safety Feature of the Near Future: Airbags on the Outside of Cars

    By Rain Noe - 21 hours ago

Continued Reading
  • Medical

    By Emily Engle - May 31, 2018

    A Clinic and Research Lab Designed to Make the Patient Experience Pleasant and Comprehensible

    A hospital, but it's fun.

    Has anyone ever thought of the hospital or doctor's office experience as pleasant, easy and comprehensive? Probably not. Does your doctor's office or local hospital look anything like this? Or this? Or this? Probably not. Let's face it—medical spaces need a facelift, from furnishings to digital screens to the

  • Visual Communication
    1 Comment

    By Core Jr - Sep 29, 2017

    Case Study: Social Activism As Brand Strategy

    Graphic designer Allyn Hughes discusses how brands are using the current political climate to their advantage

    In January, around the time of the Women's March on Washington, my pilates studio wrote an Audre Lorde quote on the chalkboard near the door: "Caring for myself is not self-indulgence, it is self-preservation, and that is an act of political warfare." At first it made me feel a kinship with the studio, because I like the quote and I admire Audre Lorde.

  • Technology

    By Arnold Martin - Feb 14, 2017

    Sponsored Post: Hands-On with Evolve 2017

    The Ultimate Hybrid Modeler

    As a designer with years of experience with parametric solid modeling in engineering CAD packages my recent experience test driving the 2017 edition of Evolve from solidThinking was a back-to-basics breath of fresh air. Evolve feels largely unhampered by the constraints of popular mechanical CAD

  • Case Study
    2 Comments

    By Ryan Eder - Nov 21, 2016

    From Design Student to CEO

    Ryan Eder, founder & CEO of award winning workout system, IncludeFitness, talks immersive research, finding key collaborators and bringing ideas to life

    Ryan Eder's idea for an inclusive workout system, The Access Strength, began as his student thesis project at University of Cincinnati. After The Access Strength took home multiple IDSA awards, including Best in Show, Eder realized that he needed to do more than travel around and share his idea—he needed to take action and bring it to life. Through years of effort and research to bring his realization to market, Eder's company, IncludeFitness, transformed into both a physical and cloud-based pla

K

{

Welcome

  • YSign In with Facebook
  • mSign In with Twitter
  • USign In with Linkedin
OR
  • jSign In with Core77 Account
  1. Forgot password?
  • Cancel

Don't have an account? Join Now

K

{

Welcome

Create a Core77 Account

  • YJoin Now with Facebook
  • mJoin Now with Twitter
  • UJoin Now with Linkedin
OR
  • jJoin Now with Email
  • Cancel

Already have an account? Sign In

By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use

K

Reset Password

Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.

  • Cancel
Today On the Core77 Network...
  • ]Design Jobs

    • Staff Industrial Designer

      Milwaukee Tool Brookfield, Wisconsin
    • Senior Interaction Designer

      TEAGUE Seattle, Washington
    • Graphic Designer

      West Elm New York
    • Senior Graphic Designer

      West Elm New York
    • Post A Job
    • View All Jobs
  • ]Design Directory

    View other design services:

    • *Hot On Coroflot

      • Jumpstart Charging Systems

        Ryan Paul
      • Beverage Dispenser

        Jonathan Smith
    •  

      • ET TOY WORK

        Rurik Tyler
      • ECCO Biom Venture TR

        Ventsislav Nikolov
    • © 2019 Core77, Inc. All rights reserved.
    • Terms
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • About
    • )
    • m
    • Y
    • '
    • S
    • © 2019 Core77, Inc. All rights reserved.
    Advertise Here