• Store
  • Design Jobs
  • Firms
  • Awards
  • Conference
e

Core77

Sign In / Join Now;
e
  • Topics
    • Product Design
    • Process
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Business
    • News
    • Furniture
    • Tools
    • Transportation
    • Education
    • Footwear
    • Impact
    • Reference
    • Video
  • Features
    • Features
    • Yo! C77 Sketch
    • Photo Galleries
    • Bizarre Inventions
    • Design Calendar
    • Weekly Maker's Roundup
    • DiResta's Cut
    • Industrial Design Tips
    • Hand Tool School
    • Tools & Craft
    • Design Experience that Matters
  • Shopping Guide
  • Projects
    • Projects
    • Firm Projects
    • Reader Projects
  • Forums
    • Forums
    • General Discussion
    • Students & Schools
    • Design Employment
    • Sketching
    • Software & Technology
    • All Forums
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • About
    • Contact
    • Advertise

Uh-Oh: Beats Teardown Apparently Used Beats Knockoffs

Fakes are becoming impossible to externally tell apart

By Rain Noe - Jun 26, 2015

  • Join Core77 Today
  • Submit your projects for publication
  • }Favorite This
  • Y1
  • m1
  • U1
  • [1
  • X1
  • H1
  • 12 Comments
U of Oregon U of Oregon

Many of you took an interest in the Beats teardown post from earlier this week, and we learned a lot about metal being added to a variety of product designs (thanks commenters!). However, a few sharp-eyed readers contacted us with disturbing allegations: Those weren't actual Beats headphones at all, they claimed.

Enter a caption (optional)

I couldn't get anyone to go on the record, which is a shame, as I would've loved for this information to be directly attributable to a Core77 reader. But here's what we were able to find out externally:

The prototype engineer who did the breakdown, Avery Louie, never mentions what model of Beats he tore down. But he refers to the price as $199, which is consistent with Beats' Solo 2 headphones. However, the color scheme in Louie's photos doesn't match the Solo 2 offerings, indicating he used Beats' discontinued Solo HD, which also retailed for $199. And here's where it starts to unravel.

Enter a caption (optional)

Louie found just two drivers, one per ear, in his teardown. But the Solo HD contains four drivers, two per ear. So it appears Louie's been given a bogus pair. Audiophile Redditor Vantt1 has gone to the trouble of highlighting some internal differences between real and fake Beats in this Imgur page, which shows a crossover circuit absent in the teardown and other discrepancies.

Image via Imgur

The question you likely have is, how could a prototype engineer be fooled into using knockoffs rather than the real deal? We'll remind you that he's tearing down products precisely because he doesn't know what's inside. One could also argue, however, that he should have been looking for dual drivers if he was familiar with the product description.

Where we can't fault Louie is in supposing these were real Beats products based on the packaging and external appearance. Pirate manufacturers have become so adept at aesthetic duplication that it is shocking. Don't believe us? Take a look at this video, where the TechBreak channel looks at real-vs.-fake Beats Solo 2 headphones side by side:

Enter a caption (optional)

Imagine that this arrived via delivery and you're examining the packaging. It is nearly dead-on identical. The only giveaway is the extra languages printed on the box (which the reviewer refers to collectively as "Chinese," but which is in fact Chinese, followed by Japanese, followed by Korean characters, followed by simplified Chinese). The real Beats packaging features only Western languages. However, unless you had both the real and fake boxes right next to each other, this would be unlikely to raise a red flag; it's common these days for lots of products to feature Asian languages on the box.

Enter a caption (optional)
Enter a caption (optional)

Opening the box, there are a couple of additional giveaways—the plastic wrapping on the fakes and the color of the serial numbers—but again, unless you already had a real pair to compare it to and knew precisely what to look for, you wouldn't realize these were indications of fakery. And even with the real and fake side by side and no idea of what to look for, a layperson would be hard-pressed indeed to spot even minor differences.

Enter a caption (optional)
Enter a caption (optional)

The Solo 2 is Beats' lower-priced offering. Their Pro model is billed as their top-of-the-line and comes with a hefty $399.95 price tag. These, too, are being knocked off—and again, you'll be astonished at how far the pirates have taken it:

Enter a caption (optional)

This is very troubling, and a much larger issue than whether manufacturers are trying to "fool" consumers with metal or not. It makes me wonder how pervasive the fakes are, and also makes me wonder if consumers will now question the numerous reviews stating Beats' sound quality is inferior; did the reviewer purchase a real pair in the store, or through the mail? Obviously if you buy a new pair of Beats for $10 on eBay, something's up; but if the fakes have infiltrated an Amazon seller and priced them closer to the real thing, it's possible your average reviewer could have unknowingly attained knock-offs. This doubt can muddy the decision-making process of a potential end user, and I think that's bad news.

However, I also sadly realize that none of this may matter. Whether you're wearing a good-sounding authentic pair of beats, a truly bad-sounding authentic pair of Beats or a worse-sounding pair of convincing knock-offs may actually make no difference; it depends on what your goal is in purchasing a particular product. In the video below, tech reviewer Marques Brownlee articulates what some commenters in the original post hinted at, about why some folks will purchase Beats regardless of reviews.

Enter a caption (optional)

The latest design news, jobs & events.
Straight to you every other week.

Join over 300,000 designers who stay up-to-date with the Core77 newsletter...

Subscribe

Test it out; it only takes a single click to unsubscribe

  • }Favorite This
  • Y1
  • m1
  • U1
  • [1
  • X1
  • H1
  • Object Culture

Rain Noe

Rain Noe is a writer and industrial designer based in New York City.

12 Comments

  • Noodle Time
    2 years ago
    Z
    2Z
    Reply

    Piracy will always be a problem with high margin goods, or things that are very easy to replicate.  They could combat this with lower prices, or more complex design.

    There is also a good chance that a lot of the components are actually the same.  A lot of chinese suppliers will sell of their 'nonconformance' parts, to avoid losing money in scrap.  And other stuff, like the bag, may actually be the same source.

    on the flip side... even legitimate goods are susceptible to internal counterfeiting.   I have seen first hand when counterfeit electrical components sneak their way in, because whoever the CM is buying from, is also buying from someone else, so accountability is low.   And even with good quality control, things slip by until they show failure out in the field.

    !Report as spam
  • Bagged Milk
    2 years ago
    Z
    1Z
    Reply

    Before people get to saying: HAHAHA MDR-7506 AREN'T FAKED.... They are actually one of the most commonly faked headphones right after Beats. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2t4viJfv0Q


    I happen to own a pair of MDR-V6's myself.... And two pairs of AKG K240's (one vintage from the 1970's, one from 2014) a Brainwavz HM5, a Logitech UE6000, Rockit R-Studio, Thinksound On1, Audio Technica ATH-EP700, Audio Technica ATH-WS77, and a few more. Also I have borrowed the ATH-M50 for a period of over a month... 
    Right now I can tell you the V6 isn't my favorite. They are bright in tonality, have a large hump in the mid through upper bass, and have some harshness in the upper frequencies.

    Now, let's have a look at a frequency response graph of the MDR-V6 from Changstar.com to back up my claims. As we can see here, they have an upward tilt, leading to thinness and an overall bright sound signature.... Quite bright, in fact. Its a gradual 12db climb from 200hz to 10khz. 

    Onto the topic of Beats... Are they trash or no? Well the old Monster Beats yes. The original Beats Solo is a dying breed. They are truly built like wet noodles, and are the bass heavy piece of crap that gave Beats a bad reputation. Going over to Innerfidelity... 
    http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/MonsterBeatsbyDrDreSoloHD.pdf we can see the SoloHD

    http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/MonsterBeatsSolo.pdf
    http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/MonsterBeatsSoloSample2.pdf
    and two samples of the Solo. Now, take a look at the two Solos. Wonderful driver matching and quality control huh? (sarcasm)
    The Monster Beats Studio measures a tad better.
    http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/MonsterBeatsStudio.pdf

    The Pro is by far the best of the original line up...
    http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/MonsterBeatsPro.pdf
    but go and compare that to the (originally) 200$ Logitech UE6000
    http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/LogitechUE6000passive.pdf
    hmmm... As we can see, Monster Beats were bad. REAL bad.
    The Studio2 is only a tad better than the Studio.
    It gains some things, but then loses others. For example, they have higher distortion than the original Studio by quite a margin. http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/BeatsStudio22014.pdf
    (though the Studio2 did fix build quality issues and made them a ton more sturdy)

    .... But then...  With the introduction of the Solo2, they broke the trend and finally introduced a headphone worthy of the price tag.
    http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/BeatsSoloII2014.pdf
    It measures wonderfully for the price, and can go toe to toe with other 200$ on ears like the V-Moda XS, Sennheiser Urbanite, and Sennheiser Momentum on ear with no problems.
    http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/SennheiserMomentumOnEar.pdf example. I do prefer the warmer tonality of the Solo2 to the MDR-V6. I also find the Solo2 to be more detailed and less grating in the treble overall. Now, the MDR-V6 is better than any of the original line up, but the solo2 has changed all that. Beats is getting better and I think it's time to commend them on this. Remember, always take a listen as well before buying. Listening to the real thing is better than any review, or any graph of measurements. Don't comment unless you've had the chance to listen to the headphones in a relatively quiet environment for at least a few songs... Sometimes, first impressions aren't reliable, so that's why I said a few songs.

    Point: Beats is now ready to play with the big boys.

    !Report as spam
  • Eric Ludlum
    2 years ago
    Z
    1Z
    Reply

    Can't wait for the Sony teardown...

    !Report as spam
  • Anth Seaton
    2 years ago
    Z
    1Z
    Reply

    We're not annoyed that someone got fooled into investigating a knock off product,  we're annoyed because it came with the sensationalist headline about poor quality and it make you guys seem like pieces of crap.

    !Report as spam
  • Bot Fake hunter
    a year ago
    Z
    Z
    Reply

    Hey, guys. CHeck out checkforfake.org It can help spot fake Beats

    !Report as spam
  • Simon Kwan
    2 years ago
    Z
    Z
    Reply

    I live in China and have ready access to many brands of fake everything. They fake cars here, so headphones are no big deal. I've seen very convincing fake Sennheisers, Bose, V-Moda, Monster, Beats, etc. Haven't yet seen a fake B&O but expect to soon. The thing is, some of the fakes actually sound pretty good. I recently acquired a new fake Beats Studio Wireless. It's the all matte black version. Build quality is really good. No problems with the Bluetooth. Stayed connected to my MacBook even from another room. As for sound quality, I don't have measuring equipment, but subjective listening tells me they're damn close to the real thing. I've listened to all the newer models of Beats (Solo2, Studio, Mixr, Pro) and even a side x side comparison doesn't reveal a substantial difference in sound quality. The fakes have good clarity, attack, and are very responsive showing no discernible distortion even when cranked up loud. The bass frequencies are more pronounced, as per the Beats sound profile, but not at the expense of clear mid or high frequencies. If I hadn't purchased these from the fakes vendor myself, I could easily have been fooled into thinking they were the real deal. The only major difference: I bought mine for 480 RMB, which is roughly $77 USD. That includes a nice semi-hard case and all the same charging and audio cables as in the real package. At that price, the vendor still makes a profit and so does the factory. This assumes the vendor buys factory direct. There may be a wholesale distributor in the middle as well. Add in transportation fees also, and you can guesstimate the actual material and labor costs total about $35-$40 USD. For a Bluetooth headphone with decent drivers and materials (the ear pads are quite comfortable, all the plastics feel and look good, and the hinges are real metal). Assuming genuine Beats are manufactured in better factories, cost still won't exceed $50. With a $380 MSRP, that's a VERY healthy margin. I don't know how much Beats sells them for at wholesale, but it's gotta be pretty pricey (perhaps upwards of $120), as they also have tons of marketing costs to cover. I'm not getting into whether Beats are good / bad / worth the money, etc. I just wanted to share my insights to other readers.

    !Report as spam
  • Pedro Moscoso
    2 years ago
    Z
    Z
    Reply

    Hey guys, this is a very interesting article. However, besides all the discussion about if the tear down denigrated the beats products or even if the product is more fashion than quality I think we are missing one more important issue here. I have heard that some of the replicas are made by the same producers of the original ones! This would be a very interesting theme to investigate, because if you think about it, where do they produce this product? (China, Taiwan, Singapore?) And where the replicas come from? Also is easier for the producer to manufacture the replicas using cheaper materials but in the same molds than the originals, with the same prints and in the same fabric! Even more, if they produce their own replicas they have the whole market for themselves. I think this is worth of a research.

    !Report as spam
    • Nick Troll
      Pedro Moscoso
      2 years ago
      Z
      Z
      Reply

      I've bought multiple knockoff electronics products while in China for factory trips. I work in the shoe industry and know that (at least for shoes) the same factories make everything from top brands down to private label products. On the same production lines, 10 feet from each other. Of the knockoff electronics that I've purchased they are all almost identical to the true branded products. The only identifiable differences on the exterior of the products are usually spelling errors on easily swapped out injected pieces. 


      I would not be at all surprised if factories were producing extra product with slightly lower quality interior parts while using the same molds and materials for the body. That being said, the knockoffs do perform well. I've never had a problem with them and am happy with the quality, not to mention the prices. 

      On top of it all there are different quality of knockoff goods as people living in China know where to find the 'good' knockoffs. 

      !Report as spam
  • Metl Mann
    2 years ago
    Z
    Z
    Reply

    So are you going to buy a legitimate pair and do a teardown to set the record straight?

    !Report as spam
  • Robert Wilkey
    2 years ago
    Z
    Z
    Reply

    One of the many reasons to not buy Beats...

    !Report as spam
    • So Ma
      Robert Wilkey
      2 years ago
      Z
      1Z
      Reply

      Right. So by that same logic, don't buy Nike shoes, Rolex watches, Louis Vuitton handbags, or pretty much anything else that might get knocked off.

      !Report as spam
      • Metl Mann
        So Ma
        2 years ago
        Z
        Z

        Just don't buy brand gear from Ebay.  Or even Amazon sometimes.  Find a reputable store, be smart.

        !Report as spam

Core77's Design Directory

View all Design Firms »

Core77 Adlets

Advertise Here

Recent Posts

  • This Brilliant Japanese Labor-Saving Device Makes Farming WAY Easier

    By Rain Noe - 2 days ago

  • Bondo Basics for Designers and Modelmakers, Part 2

    By Rain Noe - 2 days ago

  • Taking Your Business Seriously Without Taking Yourself Too Seriously 

    By Core Jr - 3 days ago

  • Second Company Develops Sustainable Mushroom-Grown Leather, Will Debut it This Saturday

    By Rain Noe - 3 days ago

Continued Reading
  • Object Culture
    45 Comments

    By Rain Noe - Jun 22, 2015

    Teardown Reveals Beats Headphones Contain Metal Weights to Give Impression of Quality

    A common industrial design trick?

    Prototype Engineer Avery Louie tore down a pair of Beats headphones to see what makes them tick (or thump) and what he found inside is pretty sad. Amidst "generic drivers" and the cost-reducing tricks of the trade many of you ID'ers are familiar with—designing plastic parts that snap together rather

  • Object Culture

    By Rain Noe - Jun 12, 2015

    Re-thinking Record Players: Pro-Ject Audio's Minimalist Form Factors

    Channeling Rams

    When we saw this photo, we thought we missed something in our History of Braun Products series. This minimalist turntable certainly looks like their handiwork: But nope, that's the Essential II model from modern-day manufacturer Pro-Ject Audio Systems, a company based in Austria. That design seems about as pared-down as

  • Object Culture
    1 Comment

    By Rain Noe - Jun 11, 2015

    How NYPD Badges are Made

    A family-run company in Brooklyn has been making them for two generations

    With any luck, you'll never see a police badge up close. And even if one is flashed in your face, afterwards as you're sitting on the curb wearing zip-ties you probably won't be thinking "Gee, I wonder how those badges are made." But for those who are curious, a Brooklyn-based

  • Object Culture
    24 Comments

    By Rain Noe - Jun 10, 2015

    Why are Electric Pencil Sharpeners Made in the '80s Better than New Ones?

    And why do we have to shop vintage just to get something that works?

    After graduating design school and finding work as a CAD jockey, I donated all of my studio materials to a young design student who needed them. Berol Prismacolors, Koh-i-Noor Rapidographs, circle and ellipse templates, French curves, you name it. I never missed any of that stuff, except one object I

K

{

Welcome

  • YSign In with Facebook
  • mSign In with Twitter
  • USign In with Linkedin
OR
  • jSign In with Core77 Account
  1. Forgot password?
  • Cancel

Don't have an account? Join Now

K

{

Welcome

Create a Core77 Account

  • YJoin Now with Facebook
  • mJoin Now with Twitter
  • UJoin Now with Linkedin
OR
  • jJoin Now with Email
  • Cancel

Already have an account? Sign In

By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use

K

Reset Password

Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.

  • Cancel
Today On the Core77 Network...
  • ]Design Jobs

    • Full Stack UXer

      LearnCore Chicago, Illinois
    • Creative Director

      Chicago Display Marketing River Grove, Illinois
    • Engineering Project Manager, Soft Goods - 113593435

      Apple, Inc. Cupertino, California
    • Industrial Designer

      Bould Design San Mateo, California
    • Post A Job
    • View All Jobs
  • ]Design Directory

    View other design services:

    • _Hand-Eye Supply

      • Trusco 2-Level Cantilever Tool Box

        $65
      • Kaweco Highlighter Color Leads 5.5x80mm 3 pack

        $7
      • Hand-Eye Supply 6 PC Screwdriver Set

        $50
    • *Coroflot Portfolios

      • Coros Omni Helmet

        Dave Windham
      • Hexa, the first ever smart air filtration mask

        Kip Nordby
    • © 2018 Core77, Inc. All rights reserved.
    • Terms
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • About
    • Y
    • m
    • '
    • X
    • S
    • © 2018 Core77, Inc. All rights reserved.
    Advertise Here